See Full Document Text
Official Journal EN
of the European Union L series
2024/2240 10.10.2024
RESOLUTION (EU) 2024/2240 OF THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT
of 11 April 2024
with observations forming an integral part of the decision on discharge in respect of the
implementation of the general budget of the European Union for the financial year 2022,
Section VI – European Economic and Social Committee
THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT,
— having regard to its decision on discharge in respect of the implementation of the general budget of the European
Union for the financial year 2022, Section VI – European Economic and Social Committee,
— having regard to Rule 100 of and Annex V to its Rules of Procedure,
— having regard to the report of the Committee on Budgetary Control (A9-0072/2024),
A. whereas in the context of the discharge procedure, the discharge authority wishes to stress the particular importance
of further strengthening the democratic legitimacy of the Union institutions by improving transparency and
accountability, and implementing the concept of performance-based budgeting and good governance of human
resources;
B. whereas the European Economic and Social Committee (the ‘Committee’) is an advisory body of the Union providing
a forum for consultation, dialogue and consensus among representatives of the various economic, social and civil
components of organised civil society from the Member States;
C. whereas the Committee contributes to the Union decision-making process and, by ensuring links between Union
policies and economic, social and civic circumstances, pursues its missions of better law making, participatory
democracy from the bottom up and promotion of Union values;
D. whereas the consultation of the Committee by the Commission or the Council is mandatory in certain cases, the
Committee may also adopt opinions on its own initiative and enjoys a wide area for referral, as set out in the
Treaties, allowing it to be consulted by Parliament;
E. whereas the Committee’s commission for financial and budgetary affairs is the Committee’s supervisory body for all
budgetary procedures and, in particular, the establishment of the budget estimates, the budget implementation, the
annual activity report, the discharge and the follow up to the annual report of the Court of Auditors (the ‘Court’);
1. Notes that the budget of the Committee falls under MFF Heading 7 ‘European public administration’, which
amounted to a total of EUR 11,6 billion in 2022, i.e. 5,9 % of Union budget spending; notes that, in 2022, the
budget of the Committee represented 1,31 % of MFF Heading 7;
2. Notes that the Court in its Annual Report for the financial year 2022 examined a sample of 60 transactions under
Administration, the same number as were examined in 2021; further notes that the Court writes that administrative
expenditure comprises expenditure on human resources including expenditure on pensions, which in 2022
accounted for about 70 % of the total administrative expenditure, and expenditure on buildings, equipment, energy,
communications and information technology, and that its work over many years indicates that, overall, this
spending is low risk;
3. Notes that as part of its audit for 2022, the Court examined the supervisory and control systems of the Committee,
in particular the implementation of internal control standards, risk management and the functioning of key controls
defined in the Financial Regulation, including ex ante and ex post controls on payments;
4. Notes that 14 (23 %) of the 60 transactions contained errors but that the Court, based on the five errors which were
quantified, estimates the level of error to be below the materiality threshold;
ELI: http://data.europa.eu/eli/res/2024/2240/oj 1/9EN
OJ L, 10.10.2024
5. Notes with satisfaction that the Court, in its Annual Report for the financial year 2022, states that it did not identify
any specific issues concerning the Committee; notes further that the Court, in its follow-up review, considered that
the recommendation made to the Committee in the Annual Report for the financial year 2019 with regard to the
need for the Committee to develop a sensitive functions policy in line with its internal control standards was
implemented in some respects;
Budgetary and financial management
6. Notes that, in 2022, the final adopted budget for the Committee amounted to EUR 152 451 643, representing an
overall increase of 5,1 % compared to 2021; notes that the remuneration and allowances budget line increased by
5 % between 2021 and 2022 due to the annual indexation of salaries; notes that the budget line for the fitting out
of premises decreased by 77 % between 2021 and 2022 and came back to usual levels after the implementation of
important refurbishment works in 2021; notes that, otherwise, the distribution of appropriations across budget
lines in the 2022 budget remained comparable to previous years’ distribution;
7. Notes that the budget implementation rate was 96,12 % in 2022, after two years of lower budgetary implementation
due to the COVID-19 pandemic and the related travel restrictions; notes that the payment execution rate followed
the same trend and reached 88,12 % in 2022;
8. Notes that the carry-over of appropriations to the year 2022 amounted to EUR 20 162 518, i.e. approximately 13 %
of the 2022 annual budget, which was substantially higher than the average in previous years; understands that this
carry-over was linked to the postponement of buildings works in 2020 and 2021;
9. Notes that the average time for payment in 2022 was 18 days, which represents a sharp decrease since 2019, when it
was 30,19 days; appreciates that, at the same time, the use of electronic invoicing rose from 58,54 % in 2018 to
88,84 % in 2022 which presumably contributed to the reduction in the time for payment over that period;
welcomes that the Committee changed its practices as result of internal audit recommendations on payment times
which was launched and closed in 2022 and contributed to a decrease in the proportion of late payments to around
10 % in 2022;
10. Notes that the Committee’s own services launched 15 negotiated procurement procedures below EUR 60 000
in 2022, mainly for expertise, studies and logistical support; noted that procurement procedures in the field of
logistics were launched by the joint services that the Committee shares with the Committee of the Regions (the
‘CoR’);
11. Notes that, in 2022, the Committee continued to improve the cost-effectiveness of its working methods, notably
thanks to hybrid work, full dematerialisation of financial circuits and reduced energy consumption; notes further
that budgetary and administrative savings were achieved through interinstitutional cooperation, notably through
the joint services with the CoR and the outsourcing of specific services to the Commission (for an annual fee) for
the handling of HR matters and the use of various IT platforms for financial management and HR, as well as the
participation in interinstitutional procurement procedures led by other institutions;
12. Is aware that the decisions pertaining to the Committee members’ allowances for attending meetings and to the
amount of such allowances are taken by the Council; regrets that, following the progressive lifting of travel
restrictions related to the COVID-19 pandemic, the Council decided against repealing the temporary 2021 decision
granting an allowance of EUR 145 for members’ remote attendance of meetings, which remained in force until
25 May 2023, when a new Council decision was adopted with a flat rate of EUR 145 per day for remote attendance
of meetings; considers that remote attendance is an important instrument for modern institutions given that, inter
alia, it reduces the costs of meetings and allows broader participation, especially during crisis situations, as
demonstrated during the COVID-19 pandemic; considers, nevertheless, that an allowance for remote attendance,
despite being reduced, is difficult for the public to understand, even more so when taking into consideration the
difference paid to the members of the Committee and members of the CoR for remote attendance; notes the several
layers of control carried out to prove that a member is attending a meeting remotely prior to the payment of the
allowance;
2/9 ELI: http://data.europa.eu/eli/res/2024/2240/ojEN
OJ L, 10.10.2024
13. Notes that Russia’s war of aggression against Ukraine created budgetary pressure for the Committee, including
through rising inflation and salary adjustments, strongly increasing energy costs and the cost of construction and
raw materials; notes in particular that energy costs increased from EUR 726 000to EUR 3 125 000between 2021
and 2022, i.e. an increase of 330 %; notes that ad hoc activities in support of Ukrainian civil society incurred direct
and indirect costs, such as the costs related to translation and interpretation to and from Ukrainian, the hosting of
Ukrainian NGOs, and security services and trainings for missions to Ukraine;
14. Notes that the 2022 budget for staff missions increased by EUR 25 000as compared to 2021, which was financed
by a budget transfer, to cover higher expenses due to the increase in flight and hotel prices in 2022 and amounted
to a total of EUR 398 974; notes that, in 2022, the President of the Committee participated in 26 missions with a
total cost of EUR 38 042, compared to 12 missions with a total cost of EUR 15 327in 2021, following the lifting
of travel restrictions after the end of the COVID-19 pandemic;
Internal management, performance and internal control
15. Notes that the Committee pursues its mission through opinions, which refer to legislative proposals made by the
Commission (referrals), own-initiative opinions, which call on the Union institutions to take action, and exploratory
opinions, which feed into the Commission’s work on its planned initiatives, and that the Committee’s positions can
be highlighted in resolutions or included in evaluation and information reports; notes that, in 2022, the Committee
adopted 202 opinion and reports which is in line with its average annual performance, excluding 2019 and 2020
when the activity of the Committee was lower; notes that the Committee also enhanced its engagement in the
political and legislative cycle by attending 345 high-level national, Union and international meetings, summits and
conferences, and by organising 116 hearings and 29 conferences;
16. Appreciates the projects launched in 2022 in respect of reinforced follow-up opinions with a view to increasing the
outreach and impact of selected opinions and improving the Committee’s capacity to prioritise its work and in
respect of the improvement of the timeliness of the delivery of the opinions of the Committee; notes that those
initiatives were complemented, at the end of 2022, by a reflection on the format of opinions, the aim of which is to
promote a more efficient and effective use of the Committee’s opinions in the legislative decision-making process;
17. Notes that, in 2022, Members of Parliament participated in meetings or events organised by the Committee on 68
occasions, which remained at the same level as in 2021, whereas the Committee members almost doubled their
participation in events organised by Parliament during the same period; welcomes that, in 2022, the Committee
focused on intensifying its relations with Parliament and on promoting the Committee’s added value, thus fostering
even closer ties between sections of the Committee and parliamentary committees;
18. Notes the wide participation of the Committee in various initiatives, including key events and annual conferences to
engage with European stakeholders; welcomes the efforts made by the Committee to enhance youth involvement in
policy-making;
19. Notes that the Committee continued to reinforce its internal control framework in 2022 with the simplification of
the financial circuits under the ‘light verification’ procedure for some low-value transactions and to develop its
policy on sensitive posts, as recommended by the Court in its annual report for the 2019 financial year; notes that,
based on the update of the list of sensitive posts throughout 2022 and at the time of the publication of the updated
list of 36 posts at the beginning of 2023, the Committee was still working on reviewing the methodology and the
risk management system, taking into account both the size of the institution and the nature of its operations; asks
the Committee to inform the discharge authority of the progress made in respect of the implementation of the
sensitive posts methodology in 2023;
20. Welcomes the Committee’s efforts in establishing a better defined and more consistent audit framework through the
finalisation of the internal audit charter and the charter of the audit committee entailing procedural rules which were
approved by the audit committee in December 2022 and adopted by the Committee’s bureau at the beginning of
2023; appreciates that the Committee’s internal audit function was reinforced in 2022, notably with the
recruitment of an administrator to its internal audit service and close coordination with the internal auditor of the
CoR in all aspects relating to the audit of joint services; notes that four audits were launched in 2022 on the topics
of late payments, meeting authorisations, the strategic cycle and the selection of delegates to the Committee’s
Consultative Commission on Industrial Change;
ELI: http://data.europa.eu/eli/res/2024/2240/oj 3/9EN
OJ L, 10.10.2024
Human resources, equality and staff well-being
21. Notes that, at the end of 2022, the Committee had a total of 706 members of staff, compared to 699 in 2021; notes
that 50 contract agents and 128 temporary agents were employed by the Committee at the end of 2022 (which
represents an increase compared to 46 contract agents and 107 temporary agents in 2021), including 19 contract
agents and 3 temporary agents with indefinite contract duration; notes, in addition, that the Committee employed
12 interim agents and 7 external members of staff working on-site, excluding external service providers in the fields
of logistics and IT; notes that, in 2022, the occupation rate of the posts in the establishment plan was 95,1 %;
22. Welcomes the continuous efforts of the Committee to improve its HR framework with a view to becoming an
attractive employer and a fully inclusive workplace where every individual is valued and can fully develop their
potential; notes that the integrated HR strategy, adopted in June 2022, is articulated around the principles of
inclusion, retention, competencies and performance; appreciates that one of its first follow-up actions was the
launch of a staff satisfaction survey in January 2023with a focus on staff engagement;
23. Underlines that the on-boarding of newcomers constitutes an important factor of strategic alignment by ensuring
that staff are informed of the rules and strategies in place in an institution; notes that induction trainings for the
Committee’s newcomers resumed in April 2022; welcomes that the Committee developed a mentoring scheme
where mentors were provided support and advice in the form of an exchange of best practices to adapt their
methods to the hybrid working environment;
24. Notes that, with a view to better distributing its scarce resources, in 2022 the Committee commissioned an external
HR mapping which confirmed the heavy workload in many different services across the Committee in light of the
scarcity of resources following the reduction of the establishment plan in 2013; notes that, as a follow-up to the
external audit on the HR mapping, the Committee started to prepare an action plan including actions in the scope
of the HR integrated strategy, such as a review of the appraisal and performance system, the development of an
internal communication strategy, the adoption of the new working conditions decision and the organisation of
regular monitoring of staff engagement; calls on the Committee to provide an update on the follow-up to the HR
mapping in 2023;
25. Notes with appreciation that a new decision on flexible working arrangements, enshrining a flexible and trust-based
policy for hybrid working, entered into force on 1 April 2022in the form of a pilot project, providing a wide range
of part-time working patterns and flexible daily and weekly arrangements for the staff; notes that around 25 % of
women and 14,4 % of men employed by the Committee applied for non-standard working patterns in 2022; notes
that the decision on working conditions provides staff with the possibility to telework up to 60 % of their working
time, provided that it is compatible with the interest of services, and to telework somewhere other than at the place
of employment 15 days per calendar year; notes that Committee staff is provided with the necessary equipment to
have good working conditions when working remotely; welcomes that the evaluation committee conducted a
survey on staff satisfaction that was launched at the end of 2022; notes that the final decision on working
conditions, following the social dialogue with staff unions and the Committee’s staff committee and legal service,
should have been adopted by the end of 2023; asks the Committee to inform the discharge authority about the
developments in this regard in timely manner;
26. Regrets that, also in 2022, the Committee was not able to provide data on cases of burnout within the Committee;
respects the data protection limitations, but reminds the Committee of the importance of anonymised statistical
data within an organisation with the purpose of aiding managerial decisions; reiterates that awareness-raising
actions, good practices in relation to workload management, communication and conflict solving, as well as return-
to-work policy, should be taken into account; understands that the adoption of the new working arrangements are a
positive step towards a more effective prevention of burnout at organisational level which should also take into
account the findings of the results of the HR mapping;
27. Notes that, in 2022, the Committee continued to employ a high proportion of female staff (64,6 % of all staff),
including at middle management level (59 % of all managers); notes that female representation at senior
management position still needs to be improved, given that only three senior managers out of seven were women at
the end of 2022; encourages the Committee to pursue it efforts in respect of gender balance, notably through
awareness raising with respect to the appointing authority and ensuring that the composition of different bodies,
including HR recruitment and selection panels, remains gender balanced;
4/9 ELI: http://data.europa.eu/eli/res/2024/2240/ojEN
OJ L, 10.10.2024
28. Welcomes the work towards the adoption of a new diversity and inclusion policy from 2022 to 2023 in consultation
with the Committee’s management, the Committee’s Joint Committee for Equal Opportunities and the Committee’s
staff committee; notes that, on top of the internal communications actions carried out, a specific awareness-raising
campaign against homophobia was carried out in December 2022; welcomes that a specific training session on
diversity and inclusion was made mandatory for managers and recommended for staff and that a dedicated course
on diversity and inclusion was offered to the members of the Committee as part of their annual training
programme; encourages the Committee to continue its discussions with Parliament with a view to joining
Parliament’s Positive Action Programme for Persons with Disabilities in order to recruit contract agents with
disabilities; reiterates its call from the 2021 discharge for the Committee to finalise an updated diversity and
inclusion strategy and action plan;
29. Notes that, while all Member States are represented among the staff of the Committee, geographical balance has still
not been reached as some nationalities continue to be overrepresented compared to others; notes that in 2022 the
Committee counted 21 % of managers from the 13 Member States that joined the Union after 2004, which
represents a slight increase compared to 19 % in 2021; reiterates its encouragement to the Committee to continue
to take action to reach a proper geographical distribution within its staff, with a particular focus on the
management level;
30. Notes that, in 2022, the Committee hosted a total of 52 trainees for a five month term, four trainees for a three
month term and two trainees on grants awarded by external public bodies; notes that all trainees with a five month
term received a monthly grant and allowance while the shorter term trainees were not entitled to any financial
contribution; welcomes that, following also the call from Parliament during the 2020 discharge procedure, a
revision of the decision on the Committee’s traineeship was launched in 2022 with the objective of discontinuing
unpaid short-term traineeships and ensuring that all trainees receive a decent remuneration; underlines that the new
decision on traineeships entered into force in July 2023, ensuring a monthly income and travel and mobility
allowances and, where applicable, a disability allowance for both long-term and short-term trainees;
Ethical framework and transparency
31. Notes that the Committee continued its internal reform process with the adoption of new rules of procedures in
March 2022 and their implementing provisions in November 2022; still regrets that the specific relations between a
Member and an official is not tackled separately in relation to harassment; notes that the rules of procedure are now
aligned and consistent with the code of conduct adopted in 2021 following the Committee’s internal audit on ethics
and integrity; asks the Committee to inform Parliament whether an evaluation of the implementation of the ethics
and integrity audit action plan was implemented as planned and what the outcome of this evaluation was;
welcomes the reflection initiated in 2022 to prepare a charter of values for the Committee’s staff, following an
inclusive and participatory process which was finalised and communicated to staff in 2023; believes that only a
zero tolerance of harassment policy will prevent the Committee from future allegations of harassment and serious
misconduct;
32. Observes that, following the entry into force of the Committee’s revised decision on whistleblowing on
15 December 2021(Decision 297/21A), as well as of the revised decision on procedures for preventing and dealing
with psychological and sexual harassment at work (Decision 090/22A), adopted on 31 March 2022, the renewed
ethical legal framework was expected to be completed with a revised decision laying down general implementing
provisions on disciplinary procedures and administrative enquiries in 2023, in coordination with the CoR; notes
that a new decision on assignments and outside activities (Decision No 141/22A) was adopted in 2022, applicable
to active staff, staff on secondment and former staff, in line with the provisions of the Staff Regulations applicable at
the time of leaving the service;
33. Notes with satisfaction that, in 2022, the Committee continued to train staff and raise awareness about the ethics
framework in place, in particular the new code of conduct, harassment and whistleblowing, and the role and
responsibilities of the ethics counsellors whose mandate started in January 2022; notes that, in 2022, 116 members
of staff, including managers and newcomers, attended internal ethics training courses and 26 members of staff
attended ethics training courses provided by the Commission and the European School of Administration; notes
that a tailor-made training course was developed and delivered to the team of ethics counsellors; welcomes that
83 % of the respondents to the staff satisfaction survey launched in 2022 showed a strong awareness of ethical
behaviour and the reinforced ethical framework of the Committee;
ELI: http://data.europa.eu/eli/res/2024/2240/oj 5/9EN
OJ L, 10.10.2024
34. Notes, as regards the harassment cases reported in the last years’ discharges, that the last settlement agreement
related to the European Anti-Fraud Office (OLAF) case OC/2018/0666/A1 was concluded on 1 October 2022, thus
allowing the Committee to fully close all requests for assistance related to that case; welcomes that, on 13 April
2022, the then Committee’s President made a public statement, published on the Committee’s website, addressing
her official apology on behalf of the Committee to all the victims, both members of staff and the former member, in
the case in question; welcomes that, by its judgment of 6 October 2022in case C-673/21(1), the Court of Justice
confirmed the legality of the measures taken by the Committee’s bureau in its decision of 9 June 2020;
35. Reiterates its call on the Committee for an external and independent investigation to specifically review the
Committee’s procedures with respect to human resources and the effectiveness thereof, with a focus on identifying
the responsibilities of the administrative hierarchy in addressing harassment claims and ensuring the well-being of
staff; rejects, despite the measures taken to enhance the ethical framework of the Committee in recent years, the
Committee’s position that such an investigation is not necessary since the measures in place allowed the harassment
case to be addressed and recalls that Parliament already expressed concerns regarding the repetitive slow reaction of
the Committee in the cases in question;
36. Notes that the European Ombudsman conducted three inquiries following complaints in 2022; notes that one case
led to an investigation, which concluded that no maladministration had taken place; notes that two other cases were
closed without investigation, the Ombudsman considering that both cases had been settled in the meantime;
37. Notes with concern that four ongoing cases of alleged harassment were still under the examination of the Committee
in 2022; asks the Committee to inform Parliament about the follow-up to those cases in a timely manner; notes that
there were no new cases of alleged harassment reported within the Committee, concerning either its staff or its
members in 2022, but is aware that allegations of harassment involving a member of staff of the Committee were
reported in another institution in 2022; asks the Committee to keep Parliament informed about the follow-up to
that case in cooperation with the other institution concerned;
38. Observes that the Committee is a civil party in the ongoing legal proceedings initiated by the Belgian national
authorities against a former member accused of misconduct that are currently before the Belgian court awaiting a
decision; asks the Committee to inform Parliament about the developments in the case in a timely manner;
39. Notes that three cases of whistleblowing were formally opened either by members or by staff in 2022; notes that all
three cases were dealt with and closed swiftly with all due respect for the protection of whistleblowers in accordance
with its decision on whistleblowing (Decision 297/21A); notes further that two cases of potential whistleblowing
were brought to the ethics counsellors in 2022 but neither of them were confirmed;
40. Appreciates the Committee’s willingness to cooperate with the investigative bodies of the Union (OLAF and the
European Public Prosecutor's Office (EPPO)); notes that, in 2022, OLAF closed two cases of alleged
misappropriation of Union funds and possible irregularities and serious misconduct concerning two members in
the absence of evidence of fraud and findings; notes with concern that OLAF launched three new cases against
members concerning potential fraud in 2023, two of which were closed the same year and transmitted to the EPPO
for examination; notes that OLAF referred one case concerning an alleged breach of the code of conduct by a
member to the Committee’s ethical committee; asks the Committee to inform Parliament about the follow-up to
that case in a timely manner;
41. Congratulates the Committee for taking the decision to formally join, as of 1 June 2023, the EU transparency register
set up by the interinstitutional agreement of 20 May 2021 between the European Parliament, the Council of the
European Union and the European Commission on a mandatory transparency register(2); notes that the Committee,
on 21 March 2023, adopted several transparency measures in accordance with the principles laid down with respect
to the EU Transparency Register, such as a recommendation for office-holding members to only meet with registered
stakeholders, the obligation for office-holding members to publish their lists of meetings and a voluntary ‘legislative
footprint’ for rapporteurs;
(1) Judgment of the Court of Justice of 6 October 2022, KN v European Economic and Social Committee, C-673/21, ECLI:EU:C:2022:759.
(2) OJ L 207, 11.6.2021, p. 1.
6/9 ELI: http://data.europa.eu/eli/res/2024/2240/ojEN
OJ L, 10.10.2024
42. Regrets that the Committee has a series of measures in place to prevent fraud but has not put an integrated anti-fraud
strategy in place yet, despite previous requests from Parliament; welcomes that the Committee has completed an
inventory on the areas which are relevant to launching an internal fraud-risk analysis, such as policies and
procedures, staff training and cooperation with other bodies, with a view to improving the anti-fraud framework;
Digitalisation, cybersecurity and data protection
43. Notes that the combined IT budget of the Committee and the CoR amounted to EUR 11 712 000in 2022, including
a reinforcement of EUR 750 000 by an internal budget transfer during the year, compared to EUR 12 860 000
in 2021, i.e. a decrease of 9 %;
44. Notes that the Committee has a digital strategy aiming to provide IT services according to the best practices of IT
management while optimising the use of human and financial resources; notes that the Committee worked on the
adaptation and development of several strategic IT tools throughout 2022 aiming to enhance the efficiency and
effectiveness of the political work of the Committee and of its administrative processes and workflows; notes that
the main IT infrastructure project in 2022 concerned an adaptation of the network typology required for the new
computer room in the Jacques Delors Building (JDE) in line with the hybrid cloud roadmap;
45. Notes that the Committee increased the amount of hybrid meetings in 2022 in order to adapt to hybrid work and
optimise its ways of working, notably by reducing the number of missions; understands that this new way of
working required a technical upgrade in terms of equipment for hybrid meeting rooms;
46. Notes that the Committee did not encounter any cyber-attacks in 2022; notes that the Committee and the CoR’s new
joint directorate for innovation and information technology is composed of three units, namely digital
transformation, digital solutions and digital platforms; notes that the unit for digital platforms is responsible, inter
alia, for cybersecurity; asks the Committee to inform the discharge authority on how the creation of this new
structure contributed to enhancing the cybersecurity preparedness of its staff, in line with the NIST (National
Institute of Standards and Technology) cybersecurity framework and in cooperation with the Cybersecurity Service
for the Union’s institutions, bodies and agencies (CERT-EU); encourages the Committee to raise the cybersecurity
awareness of their Members and staff, to carry out regular risk assessments of its IT infrastructure and to ensure
regular audits and tests of its cyber defences;
47. Notes the use by the Committee of open source technology in its own systems, notably the main operational
applications used for managing the political work of the Committee (Agora and Phoenix); notes further that the
Committee tracks the use of open source technologies in its annual IT portfolio so that they are applied to new
applications;
48. Notes that, in 2022, the Committee was progressing towards the adoption of a new framework for document
management in order to enhance transparency and accessibility; observes with interest that the Committee started
to evaluate the technical feasibility and financial implications of using the Commission’s Electronic Records
Management System (Ares) in due course;
Buildings
49. Notes that the Committee and the CoR lost 5 000m2 in office space following the take-over of the rental contract of
the former EEAS building at Belliard 100, which took effect in September 2021, and the building exchange between
the Committee and the CoR’s Belliard 68 and Trèves 74 and the Commission’s Van Maerlant 2 (VMA), which took
effect in September 2022; notes that fitting-out works in the two newly acquired buildings were necessary to enable
a denser use of the office space; welcomes, in 2022, the establishment of a joint task force on new ways of working
to reflect on possible optimisation of the way work is organised and how office space is used while reducing the
environmental footprint;
50. Notes that the total budget committed in 2021 and 2022 to the renovation of VMA from the third to the ninth floor
by the Committee and the CoR amounted to of EUR 9,54 million; notes that the renovation works undertaken by
the Committee and the CoR integrated the use of smart energy saving technologies with a strong environmental
component; asks the Committee to provide an update on the return on investment of these technological
installations;
ELI: http://data.europa.eu/eli/res/2024/2240/oj 7/9EN
OJ L, 10.10.2024
51. Notes that, in 2022, the building strategy of the Committee and the CoR focused on the geographical concentration
of the buildings which was achieved by physically connecting all the buildings used by the Committees to their main
building (JDE); welcomes the new physical connection to Parliament’s buildings which became operational in
November 2022, offering a more direct, easier and 125 m shorter pathway between the buildings of the Committee
and the CoR and the buildings of Parliament;
52. Welcomes the commitment of the Committee and the CoR to systematically apply the ‘design for all’ principle to
their infrastructure, ensuring accessibility of their building by design; notes that the Committee and the CoR took a
range of different measures to ensure accessibility of their buildings for people with various kinds of disabilities;
Environment and sustainability
53. Welcomes the sustainable practices and notably the paperless approach of the Committee and the CoR which
contributed to reducing their environmental footprint in line with the digital strategy; congratulates the Committees
on having exceeded the EMAS objectives for 2021-2025, except the objectives related to gas consumption; notes
that a budget of EUR 60 000 was earmarked for the Committee’s carbon offsetting scheme by purchasing high
quality carbon credits in 2023;
54. Notes that, in 2022, the total electricity production generated by solar panels on the buildings of the Committee and
the CoR was approximately 15,5 MWh, representing 0,25 % of the total yearly consumption of the Committee and
the CoR; notes that, as of 16 September 2022, only the JDE was equipped with solar panels; is aware that due to
administrative procedures the Committee and the CoR will face a delay before being able to extend their solar panel
installation;
55. Congratulates the Committee on establishing a business transport plan in agreement with the mobility department
of the Brussels-Capital Region following which the Committee commits to carrying out a compulsory mobility
survey among its staff every three years; notes that the Committee put in place a sustainable mobility plan aiming to
encourage its staff to use more sustainable transport means, including through a financial contribution to the public
transport subscriptions of staff or a monthly financial contribution to members of staff cycling to work; notes that
the Committee is exploring additional solutions, such as the provision of electronic bikes and the installation of
additional chargers for electric cars;
Interinstitutional cooperation
56. Welcomes the budgetary and administrative savings achieved through interinstitutional cooperation, in particular
the close cooperation established at administrative level with the CoR with which the Committee shares premises
and joint services in the areas of translation, infrastructure, logistics and IT while maintaining its full institutional
autonomy; notes that, on 1 October 2022, new joint services were created, including a new directorate for
innovation and information technology, a security and safety unit and a public procurement and financial
management unit, as part of the new cooperation agreement signed with the CoR in 2022; notes further that 470
members of staff and EUR 55 million were pooled together by the Committee and the CoR in 2022 out of which
more than EUR 30 million came from the Committee, excluding salary-related expenditure; calls on the Committee
to pursue and expand that cooperation in other areas with a view to avoiding duplication and further rationalising
the operating costs of services available in the premises shared by the Committee and the CoR; invites the
Committee and the CoR to explore the possibility of setting up a single administration for their joint services,
keeping separate directorates or units for the services dealing with matters related to their specific and independent
mandates;
57. Welcomes the Committee’s search for synergies by purchasing services from other institutions through service-level
agreements and by participating in interinstitutional coordination bodies and interinstitutional procurement
procedures; notes that Parliament notably provides interpretation services for the Committee’s plenaries taking
place on Parliament’s premises and for some meetings taking place on the Committee’s premises;
58. Welcomes the Committee’s strengthened involvement in the legislative cycle and calls on the Committee to ensure
that its opinions are shared with the members of the relevant committees of Parliament in line with the cooperation
agreement between Parliament and the Committee;
8/9 ELI: http://data.europa.eu/eli/res/2024/2240/ojEN
OJ L, 10.10.2024
59. Notes that the Committee pursued and intensified its cooperation with the Commission in 2022 in the context of
the service-level agreement with the Commission’s investigation and disciplinary office on administrative enquiries
support and in the framework of the cooperation protocol updated in 2022, reinforcing the political, legislative and
communication synergies between those two institutions, in particular in the implementation of the European
Citizens’ initiative and the European Semester; notes that, according to the updated cooperation protocol, the use of
the Committee’s exploratory opinions by the Commission was reinforced, thus strengthening the Committee’s
involvement in the Union legislative cycle;
60. Notes that the Committee plays a pivotal role in reinforcing the links with and between the national economic and
social councils of the Member States; encourages the Committee to continue fostering the cooperation on topics of
common interest and on good practices and highlighting how civil society brings its contribution to the current
challenges of the Union, notably through staff exchange and the organisation of common events;
Communication
61. Notes that, in 2022, the Committee’s overall budget for communication was EUR 1,5 million, the same amount as
in 2021; notes that this budget was primarily allocated to support the development and maintenance of the
Committee’s website, social media communication, media monitoring, media relations and promotion of major
activities and events of the Committee, such as the Civil Society Prize and the activities related to the Committee in
the works of the Conference on the Future of Europe (CoFE’) and the Committee's support for Ukraine;
62. Welcomes the adoption by the Committee of a new data driven communication strategy in October 2022, aiming to
increase the outreach of the Committee’s communication and the impact of its opinions and defining European Civil
Society Organisations (CSOs) and the other Union institutions as its main communication targets; notes further that,
in 2022, the Committee updated the rules on partnership with the aim of enhancing its strategic engagement with
CSOs through thematic events;
63. Notes that the Committee organised major hybrid events on topical issues of relevance for civil society, such as the
CoFE high-level event on ‘Shaping Europe together - the future is in your hands’, the annual youth event ‘Your
Europe your say’ for pupils and teachers of the Union and candidate countries, and the annual youth plenary
session ‘The Truth about Lies. Youth challenging Disinformation’ for students; notes that the Committee also
organised more specialised activities focusing on the Year of Youth and Russia’s war of aggression against Ukraine,
addressed to journalists and communication professionals of CSOs;
64. Welcomes that the overall reach of the Committee’s communication increased in 2022 compared to 2021, notably
through media coverage and web and social media presence; notes that the number of visits to the central Facebook
page increased by 96,9 % (57 000 visits) and the number of visits to the Instagram account increased by 97,9 %
(20 000visits) while the number of Facebook users increased by 1,1 % (6 million users), the outreach on Instagram
increased by 33 % (over 3 million users), the posts published on LinkedIn generated almost 1,2 million impressions,
and the tweets published on X (formerly Twitter) gathered over 6 million impressions; welcomes the Committee’s
participation, as of 2023, in the pilot project led by the European Data Protection Supervisor aimed at bringing
Union institutions on EU-Voice and EU-Video, which are two free, open-source social media networks, based on
Mastodon software, allowing Union institutions to interact with the public by sharing texts, images, videos and
podcasts;
65. Welcomes that the Committee ensures that citizens have open access to its documents via a dedicated electronic
register; notes that the Committee contributes to the open data portal of the Commission with its own datasets,
thus endorsing greater transparency in its operations through freely accessible data in human and machine-readable
formats and strengthening the link with citizens.
ELI: http://data.europa.eu/eli/res/2024/2240/oj 9/9