**Executive Summary**
This document is a record of discussion from the 45th EC meeting held on October 14, 2024, which grants final approval for the "Development of Affordable Healthcare Facilities" project in Angul, Barbil, Bhadrak, and Jharsuguda in Odisha. It also includes the subsequent final approval letter from the Ministry of Finance to the Government of Odisha, dated October 17, 2024, detailing the VGF share. The Government of Odisha is required to ensure various approvals are provided by October 31, 2024, and that the hospitals are operationalized by December, 2026.
**Key Points / Main Content**
* **Project Overview:**
* The project involves developing affordable healthcare facilities at Angul, Barbil, Bhadrak, and Jharsuguda in Odisha.
* It follows a Design Build Finance Operate and Transfer (DBFOT) model as a Public-Private Partnership (PPP).
* The project is under Sub Scheme -II of VGF Scheme for Pilot/Demonstration projects in Health Sector.
* **Project Timeline:**
* Construction: Phase I (50% Capacity) - 2 years from Effective Date
* Construction: Phase II (100% Capacity) - 5 years from Effective Date
* Concession Period: 32 Years (extendable)
* Hospital Operational Date: December 2026
* **Facility Details:**
* Capacity: 200 beds each for Angul and Barbil, 100 beds each for Bhadrak and Jharsuguda.
* Project Cost: Total cost and financing details are outlined, including Capex Grant, Equity, and Debt.
* Project Cost for Angul & Barbil: 97.54 INR Cr
* Project Cost for Bhadrak & Jharsuguda: 48.35 INR Cr
* **Financial Information:**
* Details of Total Project Cost, Total Capex VGF, Government of India Capital Grant, and Government of Odisha Capital Grant are specified.
* The Central Government's VGF contribution for Capex and Opex is capped as per the provided tables.
* **Government of Odisha Commitments:**
* The GoO confirmed that a change in the consortium member (CHRC replaced by Utkal Healthcare Pvt Ltd in Angul and Barbil) is permitted as per the RFP and approved by the State Empowered Committee.
* The GoO will comply with Indian Public Health Standards 2022 (IPHS-2022).
* GoO will ensure integration of healthcare scheme with PM-Jan Arogya Yojana.
* **Final Approval Conditions**
* Gol VGF (Capex and Opex) support shall be capped as per table.
* All conditions of the VGF Scheme, such as entering into Tripartite Agreement etc. shall be adhered to.
**Impact Analysis**
**Government of Odisha**
* **Impact:** Required to oversee and manage the development of the healthcare facilities.
* **Action Required:** Ensure timely approvals by October 31, 2024; Integrate its health scheme with PM-Jan Arogya Yojana; Sign the Tripartite Agreement with the Concessionaire, LFI and the DEA at the earliest.
**Concessionaire**
* **Impact:** Responsible for the construction, operation, and maintenance of the healthcare facilities.
* **Action Required:** Adhere to all conditions of the VGF Scheme.
**Ministry of Health & Family Welfare**
* **Impact:** Must ensure the project adheres to Indian Public Health Standards 2022 (IPHS-2022).
* **Action Required:** Follow standards as per IPHS-2022.
Key Entities Referenced
Odisha: The state where the development of affordable healthcare facilities is proposed in Angul, Barbil, Bhadrak and Jharsuguda.
VGF Scheme: Viability Gap Funding scheme, specifically Sub-scheme II, being used to support the development of affordable healthcare facilities as pilot/demonstration projects.
Ministry of Finance: The ministry through the Department of Economic Affairs and Infrastructure Finance Secretariat, granting final approval for VGF.
'Development of Affordable Healthcare Facilities' at Angul, Barbil, Bhadrak and Jharsuguda: The project for developing affordable healthcare facilities at the specified locations in Odisha.
Executive Committee (EC): The committee whose 45th meeting is being documented, and which considered granting final approval to the proposal.
Record of Discussion
1. The 45th EC meeting to consider granting final approval to the proposal,
‘Development of Affordable Healthcare Facilities’ at Angul, Barbil, Bhadrak
and Jharsuguda in the State of Odisha was held under the Chairmanship of
Secretary (EA) on 14th October, 2024 at 3.30 PM. The list of participants is at
Annexure I.
2. Details of the Proposal:
Project Angul Barbil Bhadrak Jharsuguda
Particulars
Affordable Affordable Affordable Affordable
Name of the Healthcare Healthcare Healthcare Healthcare Project-
Project Project- Angul Project- Barbil Project- Bhadrak Jharsuguda
Type of PPP
(BOT, BOOT, Design Build Finance Operate and Transfer
BOLT, OMT)
Location Angul, Barbil Bhadrak, Jharsuguda,
District- Angul District- Keonjhar District- Bhadrak District- Jharsuguda
Sub Scheme -II of VGF Scheme for Pilot/Demonstration projects in Health
Proposed under
Sector
Phase-I (50% Capacity) - 2 years from Effective Date
Construction
Phase-II (100% Capacity) - 5 years from Effective Date
Period
Concession 32 Years (extendable further on ROFR basis)
Period
Angul Barbil Bhadrak Jharsuguda
Capacity (No. of
200 200 100 100
beds)
Cost of the Project
120 125.5 54.4 54.4
(In INR Cr)
Sources of Project Capex Grant Equity Debt Total Opex
Financing as per Capex Grant
financial close Angul 77.00 11.00 32.00 120.0 43.6
Barbil 77.5 12.00 36.00 125.5 43.6
Bhardak 38.00 4.5 11.9 54.4 38.00
Jharsuguda 38.00 4.5 11.9 54.4 37.00
Details of TPC and VGF as approved in principle by the 40th EC and as discovered by the
market through bidding
Details Angul Barbil Bhadrak Jharsuguda
Project Cost 97.54 97.54 48.35 48.35Project Cost as per Financial 120 125.5 54.40 54.40
Close after bidding
Total Capex VGF in-principle 78.03 78.03 38.68 38.68
approved in 40th EC
Total Capex VGF as quoted by 77.00 77.5 38.00 38.00
Bidder
Total O&M VGF as in-principle 69.82 69.82 53.95 53.95
approved in 40th EC
Total O&M VGF as quoted by 43.6 43.6 38 37
Bidder
39.02 cr. 39.02 cr. 19.34 cr. 19.34 cr.
GoI capital grant out of bid
discovered VGF
37.98 cr. 38.48 cr. 18.66 cr. 18.66 cr.
GoO capital grant out of bid
discovered VGF
GoI opex grant out of bid 34.91 cr. 34.91 cr. 26.98 cr. 26.98 cr.
discovered VGF
GoO opex grant out of bid 8.69 cr. 8.69 cr. 11.02 cr. 10.02 cr.
discovered VGF
3. On behalf of the Chair, JS(ISD) welcomed the participants to the meeting and
requested Government of Odisha to make a presentation to the EC. It was appraised
that the proposal was earlier recommended for In-principle approval by the 40th EC
for developing affordable healthcare facilities at four locations viz., Angul, Barbil,
Bhadrak and Jharsuguda, in the State of Odisha. It was also appraised that the
proposal received for Final approval was duly circulated to all the EC members and
their response have also been received from the PSA.
4. The Commissioner cum Secretary, Health and Family Department,
Government of Odisha has made the presentation. The PSA stated that after In-
priniciple approval, RFP was published on 30th November 2022. The LoA was issued
to the selected bidders on 5th May 2023 and the concession agreement was signed
on 4th October, 2023. The financial close for Angul and Barbil was achieved on 19th
August, 2024 and for Bhadrak and Jharsuguda on 28th July, 2024. The PSA
informed that the quoted capex and opex VGF is within the limit of 40th EC approved
VGF.
5. After the presentation, the Chair asked the EC members for their
observations. NITI Aayog while supporting granting the final approval to the project
asked about the change in the consortium members, i.e., CHRC was substituted by
Utkal Healthcare Pvt Ltd in Angul and Barbil?
6. Ministry of Health & Family Welfare while supporting granting the final
approval to the project asked the PSA for following the standards as per Indian
Public Health Standards 2022 (IPHS-2022).7. DoE supported the grant of the final approval to the project and said that they
have no further comments to offer.
8. The Chair suggested the GoO to ensure that:
i. Remaining approvals may be provided by the GoO in a timely manner.
ii. Handholding and support may be provided by the GoO to the
concessionaire so that the health care facility start functioning at the earliest.
The chair further asked whether the GoO is thinking of integration of their own
health care scheme with the PM-Jan Arogya Yojana for enhanced impact and
outcome?
9. The GoO submitted the following to the queries raised by the EC members
and the Chair.
i. With respect to the observation on change in consortium member, the GoO
submitted that as per the RFP, this change is allowed and accordingly the
same was approved by the State Empowered Committee.
ii. GoO will comply with the provisions of IPHS-2022.
iii. The process of various approvals has commenced and the same will be
provided by 31st October, 2024.
iv. The hospital shall be operationalized by December, 2026.
v. With respect to on-boarding Jan-Arogya Yojana, GoO submitted that the
scheme is going to be integrated in such a way that none of the
beneficiaries are left out.
10. After detailed deliberations, the EC unanimously recommended the proposal
to the Hon’ble Finance Minister for granting Final Approval of VGF under Sub-
scheme II of the VGF Scheme with the following conditions:
i. GoI VGF (Capex and Opex) support shall be capped as per table below.
Details Angul Barbil Bhadrak Jharsuguda
Total Capex VGF in-principle 78.03 78.03 38.68 38.68
approved in 40th EC
Total Capex VGF as quoted by 77.00 77.5 38.00 38.00
Bidder
Total O&M VGF as in-principle 69.82 69.82 53.95 53.95
approved in 40th EC
Total O&M VGF as quoted by 43.6 43.6 38 37
Bidder
39.02 cr. 39.02 cr. 19.34 cr. 19.34 cr.
GoI capital grant out of bid
discovered VGF
GoI opex grant out of bid 34.91 cr. 34.91 cr. 26.98 cr. 26.98 cr.
discovered VGFii. All conditions of the VGF Scheme, such as entering into Tripartite Agreement,
etc., shall be adhered to.
11. The meeting ended with vote of thanks to the Chair.
***Annexure I
List of Participants
Department of Economic Affairs
1. Shri Ajay Seth, Secretary-in Chair;
2. Shri B. Purushartha, JS(ISD);
3. Ms. Arya Balan Kumari, Joint Director;
4. Ms. Anmol Waraich, Assistant Director.
Government of Odisha
1. Shri. Saswat Mishra, Principal Secretary , Finance, GoO;
2. Ms. Aswathy S., Commissioner cum Secretary, Health & Family Welfare
Department;
3. Ms. Jasmine Patnaik, Joint Secretary, Health & Family Welfare Department;
Department of Expenditure
1. Shri Pawan Kumar, Director;
2. Shri Ayush Bansal, Deputy Director.
NITI Aayog
1. Shri CPS Reddy, Senior Advisor;
2. Ms. Nidhi Arora, Consultant.
Ministry of Health & Family Welfare
1. Ms. Neha Garg, Director.
***