**Executive Summary**
This document is a record of discussion from the 49th meeting of the Empowered Committee regarding in-principle approval for VGF support for the "Development of Medical College and Hospital at Namsai, in Arunachal Pradesh under Aspirational District Programme through PPP Mode on DBFOT." The meeting was held on May 14, 2025, and the document is dated June 2, 2025. It forwards details of the discussion.
**Key Points / Main Content**
*Project Overview:*
* Project: Development of Medical College and Hospital at Namsai, Arunachal Pradesh.
* PPP Type: Design, Build, Finance, Operate, and Transfer (DBFOT).
* Sponsoring Authority: Department of Health and Family Welfare, Government of Arunachal Pradesh.
* Implementing Agency: Directorate of Medical Education, Training and Research, Government of Arunachal Pradesh.
* Concession Period: 66 years including a 7-year construction period.
*Project Components:*
* Upgrading existing 100-bedded district hospital to a 420-bed hospital.
* Developing a 100-seat medical college.
*Project Milestones:*
* Milestone I: Upgradation of hospital to 420 beds within 2 years from the appointed date.
* Milestone II: Development of the medical college within 7 years from the appointed date.
*Projected Costs & Financing (Without Grant)*
* Total Project Cost: Rs. 375.1 crore.
*Projected Costs & Financing (Including Grant)*
* Total Project Cost: Rs. 356.6 crore.
* VGF Sought Sub-Scheme II
* Capex Grant - Rs. 285.2 crore (40% Gol, 40% GoAP)
* O&M Grant - Rs. 104.98 crore (25% Gol, 15% GoAP)
*VGF Support:*
* Government of India (Gol) and Government of Arunachal Pradesh (GoAP) will provide VGF support (up to 80% of TPC).
*Recommendations and Observations:*
* Empowered Committee unanimously recommends the project for In-principle approval.
* OPD Services will be free to all patients.
* IPD service charges for paid patients shall be capped at 1.5 times of the prevailing CGHS rates of Kolkata.
**Impact Analysis**
**Secretary, Department of Expenditure, North block, New Delhi-01; CEO, NITI Aayog, Yojana Bhawan, New Delhi-01; Secretary, Ministry of Health and Family Welfare Nirman Bhawan, New Delhi-110011; Secretary, Department of Health and Family Welfare, room No-6, 5th Floor, Block 4, Civil Secretariat Itanagar, Arunachal Pradesh - 791111**
*Impact*
* Requires information and awareness of the project details, financial aspects, and recommendations.
*Action Required*
* Review the Record of Discussion for consideration and further action as required.
**Sr. PPS to Finance Secretary & Secretary (EA); Sr. PPS to OSD, DEA; Sr. PPS to JS (ISD)**
*Impact*
* Requires awareness of the project details, financial aspects, and recommendations.
*Action Required*
* Provide information and support to respective authorities based on the document's content.
Key Entities Referenced
Empowered Committee: Committee responsible for considering and granting in-principle approval for VGF support.
Development of Medical College and Hospital at Namsai, Arunachal Pradesh: The specific project proposal discussed in the document, involving the development of a medical college and hospital under the Aspirational District Programme via PPP.
VGF (Viability Gap Funding) Scheme: The scheme providing financial support to PPP projects to make them viable.
Aspirational District Programme: Government of India program aimed at rapidly transforming underdeveloped districts.
Arunachal Pradesh: The location where the Development of Medical College and Hospital project is to be undertaken.
F.No.1/14/2023-PIU
Government of India
Ministry of Finance
Department of Economic Affairs
Infrastructure Finance Secretariat
ISD Division
(PIU)
REKKK
STCs Building, Janpath New Delhi
Dated: 2"¢ June 2025
Record of Discussion 5
Subject: Record of Discussion of the 49" meeting of the Empowered Committee to consider
granting In-principle Approval for VGF support to the project proposal, “Development of
Medical College and Hospital at Namsai, in Arunachal Pradesh under Aspirational District
Programme through PPP Mode on DBFOT”.
Reference: 49" meeting held on 14" May 2025.
Sir/Madam,
The undersigned is directed to forward the Record of Discussion of the 49th meeting of the
Empowered Committee held on 14" May 2025 to consider granting In-principle approval for VGF
support to the Development of Medical College and Hospital in Namsai, Arunachal Pradesh
received from Directorate of Medical Education, Training and Research, Government of Arunachal
Pradesh (GoAP).
2. This issues with the approval of the Competent Authority. Lr
Arya Balan Kumari
Joint Director (PIU)
To,
1. Secretary, Department of Expenditure, North block, New Delhi-01
2. CEO, NITI Aayog, Yojana Bhawan, New Delhi-01
3. Secretary, Ministry of Health and Famuy Welfare Nirman Bhawan, New Delhi — 110011
4. Secretary, Department of Health and Family Welfare, room No-6, 5‘ Floor, Block 4,
Civil Secretariat Itanagar, Arunachal Pradesh - 791111
Copy to:
1. Sr. PPS to Finance Secretary & Secretary (EA)
2. Sr. PPS to OSD, DEA
3. Sr. PPS to JS (ISD)
Page 1 of 17Subject: Record of Discussion of the 49" meeting of the Empowered Committee for
considering the project proposal, “Development of Medical College and
Hospital at Namsai, in Arunachal Pradesh under Aspirational District
Programme through PPP Mode on DBFOT”.
1. The 49" meeting of the Empowered Committee was held on 14" May 2025 at 12:30
hours to consider the proposal of the Directorate of Medical Education, Training and
Research, Government of Arunachal Pradesh for the Development of Medical College and
Hospital at Namsai, in the State of Arunachal Pradesh under Aspirational District
Programme through PPP Mode on DBFOT.
2. List of attendees is placed at Annexure-l.
3. The basic details of the project are given in the table below:
Table1: Details of the project
Development of Medical College and Hospital at Namsai in Arunachal
Pradesh under Aspirational District Programme Through PPP Mode on
DBFOT
| Design, Build, Finance, Operate, and Transfer (DBFOT)
Department of Health and Family Welfare, Government of Arunachal
Pradesh
Directorate of Medical Education, Training and Research, Government
of Arunachal Pradesh
The concession period of the proposed project is 66 years including
the construction period of 7 years
Development Components Hospital + College
Existing Bed 100 (under construction)
Proposed Bed 320
Proposed Medical Seats 100
Project Milestones
‘Upgradation of existing 100 | Development of 100 Seat
bedded District Hospital to 420 | Medical College
beds
On the day of 7" anniversary
On the day of 2TM anniversary from _| from the appointed date
the appointed date
The scheduled construction completion date shall occur on the day
of 7‘ anniversary from the appointment date.
Page 2 of 17-
Buildings 120.88 60.67 181.55
Furniture & 6.40 7.55 13.95
Fittings
Plant & 19.00 9.26 28.26
Machinery
Medical 70.00 5.00 75.00
Equipment
Contingency 2.16 0.82 2.99
Consultancy 2.16 0.82 2.99
Financing 3.03 1,15 4.18
Cost
Total Capital 223.63 85.29 308.93
Cost
Inflation 25.1 21.8 46.9
Interest 3.4 9.9 19.3
During
Construction
Total Project 258.13 116.99 375.1
Cost
including all
the soft costs
TPC (Including the Grant): Rs.356.6 crore
Buildings +20.88 60.67 181.55
Furniture & 6.40 755 13.95
fittings
Page 3 of 17Pea 19.00 9.26 28.26
machinery
y Mealeal 70.00 5.00 75.00
| equipment
Contingency 2.16 0.82 2.99
| Consultancy 2.16 0.82 2.99
Financing cost 0.61 0.23 0.84
p toe varia 221.21 84.36 305.57
| Cost
Inflation 24.90 21.60 46.40
| Interest During
| Construction 3.20 1.30 4.60
(IDC) :
PToatail Projie ect 249.31 107.30 356.60
a) Drugs and Medicines
b) Diagnostic Services
c) IPD Services
d) Pharmacy
e) Medical College
f) Hostel Fee
a) OPD Services: Concessionaire shall provide OPD services free of
cost to paid as well as free patients.
b) Drugs and Medicines: All essential drugs listed under National List
of Essential Medicines shall be provided free of cost to free patients as
part of OPD services under applicable laws. Paid patients shall bear
the cost of the drugs that are prescribed and/or administered to them.
c) Diagnostic Services
- Concessionaire to provide OPD related diagnostic service (as per
IPHS list) free of cost to all Patients (Free and paid Patients)
- OPD related diagnostic service (except the IPHS list) and others not
covered in any insurance shall be chargeable to Paid patients up to 1.5
times of CGHS rates (Authority to reimburse the same for the free
patients as per CGHS rates)
- Concessionaire may reimburse under the concerned insurance
scheme for IPD related diagnostic services to patients covered under
such scheme
d) IPD Services:
- Concessionaire shall provide free IPD services to free patients up-to
free beds/bed days
- Concessionaire shall provide IPD services to paid patients on
remaining beds, at rates not exceeding the 1.5 times the CGHS Ranchi
Page 4 of 17rates
e) Medical Education Fees:
Concessionaire shall charge fees as decided by proposed medical
education fee fixation committee to all students at Medical college.
Debt and equity in the ratio of 70:30; grant has been considered upto
80% of the Total Project Cost and 40% of the Opex Cost.
The Government of Arunachal Pradesh would provide the existing
District Hospital plot (4.3 acres) and 15-acre land parcel on Deobeel
Village on nominal annual lease rent of Rs.1 for development of Medical
College and Hospital.
VGF Sought under Sub-Scheme II
¢ Capex Grant - Rs. 285.2 crore
40% from Gol — 142.60
40% from GoAP — 142.60
¢ O&M Grant — Rs. 104.98 crore
25% from Gol - 65.6
15% from GoAP — 39.38
The Concession Agreement for the project is based on the Model
Concession Agreement for Medical Education issued by NIT| AAYOG
and published tender documents for the development of medical
colleges in 6 unserved districts in Uttar Pradesh - Baghpat, Hamirpur,
Mahoba, Kasganj, Mainpuri and Hathras on PPP mode with VGF support
from Government of India
Lowest VGF (summation of capital grant and NPV (at 10% discount
rate) of O&M cost for first five years after COD of phase-1.
However subject to a manimum of 80% of the estimated project cost
as capital grant that may be sought by bidder and 40% of NPV of O&M
cost quoted by bidder for first 5 years after COD of Phase 1 as
| operational grant
Single-stage two envelope
CAPEX Grant of 40% (Rs. | 40% from Gol — Rs. 142.60 crore
| crore) 40% from GoAP — Rs. 142.60 crore
| NPV of O&M Grant (Rs. | 25% from Gol — Rs. 65.60 crore
| crore) 15% from GoAP — Rs. 39.38 crore
| Gol Contribution (Rs. | Capex Grant: Rs. 142.60 crore +
| Crore O&M Grant Rs. 65.60 crore
Total = Rs. 208.20 crore
GoAP Contribution (Rs. | Capex Grant: Rs. 142.60 crore +
| crore) O&M Grant Rs. 39.38 crore
Page 5 of 17Total = Rs. 181.98 crore
Project NPV @ WACC (Rs. crore) 71.4
_| Project IRR with VGF 10.10%
| Equity IRR 15.2%
. On behalf of the Chair, Joint Secretary (ISD) welcomed the attendees to the meeting
and requested the Department of Health and Family Welfare, Government of
Arunachal Pradesh (GoAP), to make a presentation to the Empowered Committee
(EC). With the permission of the Chair, the Secretary, HFW, GoAP made a detailed
presentation on the “Development of Medical College and Hospital in Namsai,
Arunachal Pradesh’.
. The primary purpose of the proposed project is to provide tertiary healthcare facility
by upgrading the existing 100-bed district hospital to a 420-bed district hospital along
with the development of a 100-seat medical colleges with ancillary facilities in the
Namsai district, Arunachal Pradesh. The State population is projected to be 17.19 lakh
by 2036, and the State currently has only one medical college, falling short as per the
URDPFI Guideline (Urban and Regional Development Plans Formulation and
Implementation) which states that one medical college per 10 lakh population is
required. At present, the tertiary healthcare is limited to the western region, leaving
eastern areas like Namsai underserved. The proposed upgradation and development
of the hospital and the medical college in Namsai through a Public-Private Partnership
(PPP) model would address this regional imbalance, enhance access to advanced
care, and increase the supply of medical professionals, while reducing the financial
burden on the State.
. Out of the total 27 acres site, 15 acres will be handed over to the concessionaire for
developing a 320-bed hospital and a 100-seat medical college. The remaining 12
acres will be retained by the Authority for future expansion. Additionally, existing 100
bed district hospital covering 4.3-acre land will also be handed over to the
concessionaire from the COD of Phase-1. The concession period of the proposed
project is 66 years including the construction period of 7 years. The hospital shall be
upgraded to 420 bedded hospital in 2 years from the appointed date. It is estimated
that the proposed hospital may achieve 80% occupancy within seven years from
appointed date and accordingly the medical college shall be developed within the 7"
year from the appointed date.
. Under the proposed project, the Concessionaire shall be responsible for augmenting,
designing, constructing, operating, maintaining, and transferring the District Hospital
to serve as a teaching hospital for the Medical College, in compliance with all relevant
standards, laws, permits, and industry practices. The proposed project is in the
Page 6 of 17northeastern region of India, where development is limited, and private sector interest
is low due to poor financial returns. The Total Project Cost (TPC) without considering
grant component and including soft costs is Rs. 375 crore. The TPC considering grant
component and soft costs is Rs.356.6 crore. To encourage private participation, the
Authority is proposing to admit the proposal under Sub-Scheme II. The Authority is
seeking 80% support for construction costs (40% of Rs.356.6 crore by Govt. of India
(Gol) and 40% of Rs. 356.6 crore by GoAP) and 40% support for operating costs (25%
by Gol and 15% by GoAP) with a total grant component of Rs. 208.2 crore from the
Govt. of India and Rs. 181.98 crore from the Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh.
8. After the presentation, the Chair asked the EC members for their observations. DOE
supported the proposal and stated that ‘hey have no further comments to offer.
9. Secretary, Ministry of Health and Family Welfare (MoHFW) made the following
observations and suggestions:
a) Is the OPD services free of cost for all patients? If yes, whether this cost is
reimbursed under NHM or PMJAY?
b) Whether the essential drugs and diagnostics are free for OPD and IPD paid
patients?
c) What is the arrangement in the existing district hospital with regard to the free
drugs and diagnostics?
d) Have all the NHM requirement been complied or not?
10.PD, NITI Aayog raised the following chcervations:
a) The project proposes a total of 420 beds, with 164 free and 256 paid beds, where
paid beds are to be charged at 1.5 times the CGHS rate for paid patients. It must
be assessed whether this pricing is competitive and aligned with the prevailing
rates of the private hospitals in the region.
b) The Authority must provide a comprehensive and itemized list of all infrastructure
and facilities the Concessionaire is required to develop under the proposed project
to ensure clarity on scope and deliverables.
c) The presentation includes a provision for future expansion, which is not reflected
in the concession agreement. This provision must be incorporated into the
concession agreement in line with standard guidelines.
41.JS (ISD) highlighted the following suggestions and observations:
Page 7 of 17a) The construction timeline for developing a 100-seat medical college and
subsequent upgradation to a 420-bed facility spans over seven years, which
seems excessively long for the construction. The construction period should be
reviewed and potentially reduced to 5 years.
b) The financial model does not account for potential revenue streams such as
parking, cafeteria, MD programmes etc. Including potential revenue streams can
reduce VGF grant requirement.
12. The Chair made the following observations:
a) What are the project milestones considered for capital expenditure?
b) Whether the 100 bedded district hospital is still under construction? If yes, what is
the source of funding for its construction?
Cc) The government transition support in terms of manpower is provided to the
Concessionaire for a period of five years. The transition support should taper off
during the 5-year period as the Concessionaire brings its own manpower.
d) At present, there are no staff available with the district hospital as the same is
under construction. How does the Authority intent to recruit the hospital staff and
hand it over to the concessionaire? What level of medical specialties will be
available, and how will the Concessionaire ensure adequate staffing, especially if
there is currently no staff in place? The project should clearly outline the staffing
plan for both the district hospital and the medical college.
Does the proposed project clearly define the level of healthcare services which
shall be provided? Whether the facility will offer only secondary care or also include
tertiary care?
f) The proposed project allocates free to paid patient beds in a 40:60 ratio, whereas
similar healthcare projects in Uttar Pradesh and Odisha followed a 50:50 ratio.
What is the rationale for this allocation?
g) Are there any KPIs fixed for the concessionaire for the development and O&M of
the tertiary care hospital and the medical college? And what are the damages if
the concessionaire failed to comply with such KPIs?
Since the State population of Arurachal Pradesh is around 14 lakh, reserving a
fixed 50% of medical college seats to the State students quota may lead to
underutilization of seats. Therefore, a more flexible provision such as reserving up
to 50% may be considered.
Page 8 of 17What is the mechanism for fee determination and its escalation for medical
college?
i) Whether the State Government strictly adheres to the PMJAY guideline or are
there any deviations?
k) The district population of Namsai is approximately a lakh. Given this, the viability
and utilization of a 420-bedded district hospital must be critically assessed. The
Authority may provide references to similar cases, if any, where such capacity has
been effectively utilized in low-population regions.
The proposed medical college is set to be operational in 7 years. Is the VGF grant
infusion be over a period of seven years i.e. for the hospital for the initial years and
for the medical college in the later years?
13.Department of HFW, Government of Arunachal Pradesh submitted the following
replies to the above observation: -
a) Yes, OPD services are for all patients and there is no reimbursement for OPD
services under any scheme.
b) The essential drugs shall be given at free of cost to all the free patients coming
under OPD and IPD categories. The paid patients have to bear the cost of the
drugs with no reimbursement provisions. The diagnostic service for free patients
shall be borne by the concessionaire as mentioned in the Schedule P of the
Concession Agreement. The OPD related Diagnostic services which are not
included in Schedule P and IPD related Diagnostic Services which are not included
under any Insurance Scheme for IPD Packages shall be reimbursed by the
Authority at the prevailing CGHS Kolkata rates.
The District Hospital is under construction and the NHM norms shall be followed
after operationalization of the hospital with respect to drugs and diagnostics.
Yes, the proposal is in accordance with NHM norms.
The provision of 1.5 times of CGHS rate for paid patients is an upper cap provided.
The concessionaire has the flexibility to fix the rates within the range as specified.
The proposed medical college and hospitals are to be developed adhering to the
NMC norms which is specified in the Concession Agreement. Additionally, the
bidders are encouraged to submit their respective bids after visiting the Project site
and making their own assessment of the site conditions, facilities, state of clinical
and para-clinical facilities, etc.
Page 9 of 17There is no provision of future expansion to be undertaken by the concessionaire.
g)
The future expansion mentioned in the presentation is with respect to the land
retained by the Authority for future expansion if required.
The district hospital will be upgraded from 100 to 420 beds within the first 2 years.
h)
After the upgradation of the hospital, to ensure the required 80% bed occupancy,
a 3-year stabilization period is planned. Consequently, the medical college
development shall take place in the S$ and 7" year. Thus, while the total duration
is 7 years, the effective construction period is 4 years only, ensuring regulatory
compliance, operational readiness, in line with the NMC guidelines.
The MD programs cannot be considered as a revenue stream, as they involve
significant expenditure. It also includes mandatory stipends for postgraduate
students as well. Moreover, many private institutions are currently facing
challenges in operating MD seats. The other revenue sources such as parking,
cafeteria, etc., are pass through revenues. Therefore, the same has not been
accounted in the financial analysis.
The proposed project has two milestones, phase 1 (2 Years) shall include
upgradation of existing 100 beds District hospital to 420 beds. The capex phasing
for phase 1 is 40% in the first year and 60% in the second year. The phase 2 (5
years) shall include the development of 100 seat Medical College. The medical
college shall be developed within 2 years with a capex phasing of 30% in the first
year and 70% in the second year.
Yes, the 100 bedded District hospital is under construction and shall be completed
k)
by the Authority before the appointed date. The funding for the development shall
be through the 15"" Finance Commission grant.
The transition support to the concessionaire is provided for a period of five years.
However, to ensure that the support does not end abruptly, the concessionaire has
given the flexibility either to extend or to reduce the transition support based on the
concessionaire’s requirement.
m) The Authority is trying its best to recruit the required medical manpower. All the
super specialty facilities will be developed by the concessionaire. The
concessionaire is responsible to recruit additional staffs for operating the facilities
in line with the NMC norms.
n) As per the proposal, the concessionaire will provide super specialty facilities for
tertiary healthcare services, in line with NHM norms.
Page 10 of 170) The 40:60 ratio of free to paid patient beds has been considered to ensure private
sector participation and financial viability of the project.
p) The KPIs for the concessionaire are incorporated at Schedule Q of the DCA which
are governed by NMC guidelines. If the concessionaire fails to comply with the said
KPls, then the termination clauses will be applicable in line with the concession
agreement.
q) The 50% seats were reserved for the state students quota as per the NMC norms
and State guidelines.
r) The fee and the fee escalation in the medical college seats would be determined
and notified by Medical Education Fee Fixation Committee constituted by the
Authority.
s) There is no deviations and the reimbursements under PMJAY are as per the
PMJAY financial guidelines only.
t) The proposed 420-bedded hospital is a requirement under NMC norms to support
a 100-seat medical college. There is a significant shortfall in tertiary care services.
It is assessed that the people from eastern region of Arunachal Pradesh shall also
be utilizing the services of the proposed hospital. Currently an occupancy rate of
90% is observed in the hospitals of Arunachal Pradesh.
u) JS(ISD) has informed that the sought capex support shall be utilized for both the
development components i.e. for the upgradation of the district hospital (in the
initial two years) and the development of medical college (in the 6" and 7" year).
The grant disbursement will be in accordance with the VGF guideline.
14.Secretary, Ministry of Health & Family Welfare was requested to assess the needs
considering low population in the area, and project structuring in terms of fee structure,
strength of the medical college, transition support, etc. The ministry vide their O.M.
dated 27.05.2025, which is annexed at Annexure II, has conveyed ‘in principle’ support
for the proposal and made certain specific suggestions. Those have been
incorporated in the recommendations of the Empowered Committee.
Recommendations
15.Considering the above discussions, the Empowered Committee unanimously
recommend the project, “Development of Medical College and Hospital at Namsai in
Arunachal Pradesh through PPP Mode on DBFOT” to the Competent Authority for In-
principle approval under the Sub Scheme-I| of the VGF scheme. VGF support up to
80% of TPC (first 40% of the TPC by Guvt. of India) and up to 40% of the NPV of O&M
Page 11 of 17cost for the first five years after COD (first 25% by Govt. of India and 15% by Govt. of
Arunachal Pradesh) shall be provided subject to the following observations:
1) The Capex VGF from Govt. of India is capped at 40% of Total Project Cost i.e., Rs.
142.60 crore and will not increase in case of any further increment in Total Project
Cost.
2) The O&M VGF Grant from Govt. of India shall be subject to the lower of:
(i) O&M Grant for the year as approved by the EC;
(ii) Annual O&M grant quoted by the concessionaire at the time of the bid;
(iii) 25% of the actual O&M cost incurred during the FY as certified by the
Statutory Auditor.
3) The maximum VGF recommended ‘< as follows:
Amount Rs. in crore
Estimated Grant from Gol Rednatye Grains inen
GoAP
T(Roet.a li nP rcorjoercet) Coosst Maximum Opex Grant ii Opex Grant
lincluding grant | C2PEXNGF | (25% of NPV | = (15% of NPV of
99 admissible | of the O&M _. the O&M Cost
and soft costs) : admissible
(40% of Cost for first for first 5
TPC) 5 years nee ears
: TPC) y
356.60 142.60 65.60 142.60 39.38
HotelIigvant 208.2¢ 181.98
contribution
4) Given that a 420-bed hospital is being proposed for a district with an approximate
population of one lakh, the projected catchment area appears insufficient to justify
the hospital’s capacity. This raises a significant concern regarding optimal resource
utilization. The public interest should be ascertained and such assessment falls
outside the purview of the Empowered Committee. The same to be undertaken by
the Authority, in consultation with the Secretary, Ministry of Health and Family
Welfare (MoHFW).
Page 12 of 17The provisions for penalties to be imposed on the Concessionaire in case of delay
5) in the construction or postponement of the commercial operations should be spelt
out clearly and incorporated in the Draft Concession Agreement (DCA).
In case of any downward revision in the number of seats in the medical college
6) and the number of beds in the hospital from 100 seats and 420 beds respectively,
based on any lower need assessment and requests at the pre-bid consultation
stage, GoAP should approach the Empowered Committee as any such revision
will have significant reduction in the upfront cost requiring reassessment of the
VGF support.
The fee for the medical education seats should be decided by the Fee Fixation
7) Committee in line with the prevailing NMC norms. The DCA should mention the
‘norms as amended from time to time’.
GoAP should consider requiring the Concessionaire to bear the salaries of the
8) existing employees of the District Hospital during the transition period of 5 years
or incorporate any other suitable provision to create an incentive for the
Concessionaire to recruit its own staff well in time instead of merely relying on the
government staff.
GoAP should provide the figures of total families in the state and the percentage
9) of families covered under PMJAY/CMAAY in the bid document so that the potential
bidders can do a better revenue forecasting leading to a more competitive bidding
and possibly lower VGF. However, provision to factor in impact of any modifications
in the said schemes may also be provided.
10)The mechanism for determination of the charges for OPD/IPD services and any
other services may be decided/determined by the State Government considering
market amenability of the project and as well as affordability of such services.
11)The following shall be considered as the pre-determined user charges/tariffs and
shall be appropriately incorporated in the concession agreement:-
(i) For paid patients, the IPD service charges shall be capped at 1.5 times of the
prevailing CGHS rates of Kolkata.
(ii) If CGHS cease to exists in the future without any successor scheme, then the
user charges/tariffs for paid patients along with escalation mechanism shall be
revised mutually by the Authority and the concessionaire and shall be recorded
in a supplementary agreement to the concession agreement after factoring in
the VGF granted under the scheme.
Page 13 of 17(iii) OPD services shall be free to all patients. The concessionaire to provide OPD
rated diagnostic service as per IPHS list free of cost to all the free and paid
patients. OPD related diagnostic service (except the IPHS list) and others not
covered under any insurance scheme shall be chargeable to Paid patients up
to 1.5 times of CGHS rates. Authority to reimburse the same for the free
patients as per CGHS rates.
(iv)In case, any regulatory/statutory mechanism subsequently comes into
existence for determination of these user charges/tariffs from time to time, then
such regulatory/statutory mechanism shall determine the user charges/tariffs
for remaining concession period factoring in the VGF granted.
(v) For medical college fees, the Fee Fixation Committee shall determine the fees
of the seats factoring in VGF granted to the project.
42)Necessary amendments to the bid documents (including Concession Agreement)
will be made to incorporate suggestions of Empowered Committee.
13)The Authority to undertake legal vetting of the project documents post
incorporation of the changes. A copy of the revised project documents be
submitted to the EC members for record purpose.
14) ‘Final Approval’ for VGF support is contingent upon compliance of all conditions of
the VGF Scheme.
15)Revalidation of ‘In Principle’ Approval of the PPPAC from VGF angle is required for
following pre-bid changes in the anfroved project documents:
(i) Any downward revision in the number of medical education seats or hospital
beds.
(ii) Any change in the formulation of pre-determined user charges/tariff.
(iii) Any change in concession period by more than 20%.
(iv) Any changes having impact on In-Principle approved amount of VGF for Govt.
of India, on the higher side.
(v) Any change falling outside the threshold criteria as stated above shall be
appraised by the PSA without any need of revalidation by the Committee and
the PSA shall proceed with the process accordingly.
16. The meeting ended with vote of thanks ‘o the Chair.
Page 14 of 17Annexure-l
List of the participants of the 49" meeting of the EC
a) Department of Economic Affairs, Ministry of Finance
1. Shri Ajay Seth, Secretary, EA- In Chair
2. Shri Baldeo Purushartha, JS (ISD)
3. Ms. Arya Balan Kumari, Joint Director
4. Shri Rajender Singh, SO (PIU)
5. Shri Manjeet Yadav, ASO
b) Department of Expenditure
1. Shri Pawan Kumar, Director, DoE
c) NITI Aayog
1. Shri. Partha Reddy, Programme Director
d) Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, Government of India
1. Ms. Punya Salila Srivastava, Secretary, H&FW
2. Ms. V.Hekali Zhimomi, Additional Secretary, H&FW
3. Ms. Poonam Meena, Director, Health
e) Department of Health and Family Welfare, Government of Arunachal
Pradesh
1. Ms. Ira Singhal, Special Secretary,
2. Dr. Hage Ambing, Director of Medical Education, Training and Research
KKK
Page 15 of 17Annexure-ll
File No.:H.11019/04/2025-PPPCell
Government of India
Ministry of Health & Family Welfare
Department of Health & Family Welfare
(Public Private Partnership Cell)
Nirman Bhawan, New Delhi
Dated: 27-05-2025
OFFICE MEMORANDUM
Subject: ‘In- Principle’ approval of Department of Health & Family Welfare-
Development of Medical College and Hospital at Namsai, Arunachal Pradesh
in PPP Mode- regarding.
In pursuance of the deliberations in the meeting of thé:mpowered
Committee on 14.05.2025, the undersigned is directed to convey this Department's
‘in-principle' approval to the proposal of the Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh for
development of Medical College and Hospital at Namsai, Arunachal Pradesh in
Public Private Partnership (PPP) Mode with the following observations:
i) The provisions for penalties to be imposed on the Concessionaire in case the
construction timelines for the project are not met need to be spelt out clearly and
be incorporated in the Draft Concession Agreement (DCA). The Project
Sponsoring Authority (PSA) may consier the same.
ii) During the pre-bid meeting, in case the Private Players request for a 50 seat
medical college and 220 bedded Hospital in the initial phase, the GoAP may
consider the same. The PSA may consider incorporating a provision in the DCA for
future expansion of the medical college in such a scenario.
iii) As informed by GoAP, 50% of the seats shall be charged as per the prevailing
existing Government Medical College fees in the State and fees for rest 50% of the
seats shall be decided by the Fee Fixation Committee, which is in line with the
prevailing NMC norms. The DCA may refer to norms as amended from time to
time.
iv) The transition support for the existing employees of the District Hospital is 5
years. During this period, the entire salary cost of the existing employees shall be
borne by the Authority. Considering the same, there is no financial incentive for the
Concessionaire to get their own manpower. Hence, it is suggested that GoAP may
consider if the Concessionaire may be asked to bear the salaries of the existing
employees of the DH for the said period of 5 years or incorporate any other
suitable provision in this regard..
v) It is assumed that most of the patients that come for IPD treatment in the
proposed facility shall be under the PMJAY/CMAAY schemes for which the State
shall provide the requisite reimbursement to the Concessionaire. GoAP may
consider providing the figures of total families in the state and the percentage of
families covered under PMJAY/CMAAY in the bid document so that the potential
Page 16 of 171/3770170/2025
FileNo.:H.11019/04/2025-PPPCell
b ai nd dd er ps
o
sc sa in
b
ld yo la
o
b we et rt er
V
Gr Fe .v en Hu oe
w
f eo vr ee rc ,a st pi rn og
v
il se ia od ni ng
t
ot o fa
a
cm to or
r
e ic no mp ie mt pi at ci tv e ob fi dd ai nn yg
modifications in the said schemes may also be provided. Di, g. i. tally si; gned by
MANOJ KUMAR SINHA
Date: 27-05-2025
11:39:13 (M.K.Sinha)
Director
Phone: 011-23063483
Email: mk.sinha26@nic.in
To
Ministry of Finance, Govt. of India
Department of Economic Affairs
(Kind attention: Shri B. Purushartha, Joint Secretary)
5th Floor, Jawahar Vyapar Bhavan,
New Delhi-110001
iq of \4
Fage