**Executive Summary:**
The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) issued the Master Direction Reserve Bank of India Variation Margin Directions, 2022, regarding the exchange of variation margin (VM) for non-centrally cleared derivatives (NCCDs). These directions, effective from December 1, 2022, outline the requirements for calculating and exchanging VM. The directions are issued under Section 45W of the Reserve Bank of India Act, 1934.
**Key Points / Main Content:**
* **Applicability:**
* These directions apply to non-centrally cleared foreign exchange, interest rate, and credit derivative contracts entered into on or after December 1, 2022.
* Genuine amendments to existing derivative contracts before this date do not qualify as new contracts.
* Does not apply to physically-settled foreign exchange forward and swap contracts
* Does not apply to transactions where one counterparty is the Government of India, State Governments, a Foreign Sovereign, a Central Bank, Bank for International Settlements or Multilateral Development Banks, or between entities of the same consolidated group.
* **Covered Entities:**
* **Domestic Covered Entities:**
* Entities regulated by a financial sector regulator (including branches of foreign banks in India) with an Average Aggregate Notional Amount (AANA) of outstanding NCCDs of ₹25,000 crore and above on a consolidated group-wide basis.
* Other resident entities with an AANA of outstanding NCCDs of ₹60,000 crore and above on a consolidated group-wide basis.
* **Foreign Covered Entities:**
* Non-resident financial entities with an AANA of outstanding NCCDs of USD 3 billion and above on a consolidated group-wide basis.
* Other non-resident entities with an AANA of outstanding NCCDs of USD 8 billion and above on a consolidated group-wide basis.
* AANA is calculated as the simple average of the total notional amount of outstanding NCCDs at the end of March, April, and May of a year.
* **Variation Margin Calculation and Exchange:**
* VM must be calculated daily and exchanged no later than three local business days from the transaction or recalculation date.
* VM should fully collateralize to market or settle to market the mark-to-market exposure.
* VM is calculated and exchanged on an aggregate net basis under a single, legally enforceable netting agreement.
* A minimum transfer amount (not exceeding ₹3.5 crore) may be applied.
* **Eligible Collateral and Haircuts:**
* **Between two Domestic Covered Entities:** Indian currency and debt securities issued by Government of India and State Governments or Rupee bonds issued by persons resident in India with AAA rating.
* **Between a Domestic Covered Entity and a Foreign Covered Entity:** Indian currency, freely convertible foreign currency, debt securities issued by Government of India and State Governments, debt securities issued by foreign sovereigns with AA- rating and above, or Rupee bonds issued by persons resident in India with AAA rating.
* Risksensitive haircuts must be applied to the value of collateral received, as per the schedule in the Annex.
* Securities issued by either counterparty or their related parties cannot be accepted as collateral.
* **Collateral Treatment:**
* Cash collateral received by banks is not treated as deposits.
* Cash collateral received by Authorised Dealers is not treated as borrowings.
* Counterparties may pay interest on cash collateral and rehypothecate, repledge, or reuse collateral.
* **Cross-Border Transactions:**
* Domestic Covered Entities can comply with either these directions or comparable margin requirements in a foreign jurisdiction.
* Comparability assessment should be based on BCBS-IOSCO guidelines and a legally enforceable netting framework.
* Domestic Covered Entities must have a Board-approved policy for comparability assessment.
* **Dispute Resolution:**
* Counterparties must have appropriate dispute resolution policies.
* In case of disputes, the non-disputed amount should be exchanged first, and efforts should be made to resolve the dispute promptly.
**Impact Analysis**
**Domestic Covered Entities:**
* *Impact:* Must comply with the new margin requirements for NCCD transactions with other Domestic Covered Entities and Foreign Covered Entities. They are expected to manage risks associated with physically settled foreign exchange forward and swap contracts.
* *Action Required:*
* Establish processes to determine if a counterparty is a Domestic or Foreign Covered Entity.
* Calculate AANA to determine if they are a Domestic Covered Entity.
* Update policies and procedures to comply with the VM calculation, exchange, and collateral requirements.
* Implement a Board-approved policy for comparability assessment of foreign jurisdictions' margining frameworks, if intending to comply with those frameworks.
* Establish appropriate dispute resolution policies and procedures.
**Foreign Covered Entities:**
* *Impact:* May be subject to these margin requirements when transacting with Domestic Covered Entities.
* *Action Required:*
* Provide declarations to Domestic Covered Entities regarding their status as a Foreign Covered Entity.
* Comply with the VM requirements or ensure compliance with a comparable foreign jurisdiction's framework.
**Financial Sector Regulators (RBI, SEBI, IRDAI, PFRDA):**
* *Impact:* Need to oversee and enforce the implementation of these directions for the entities they regulate.
* *Action Required:*
* Incorporate these directions into their supervisory frameworks.
* Monitor compliance by regulated entities.
Key Entities Referenced
Reserve Bank of India: The central bank of India, which issued the Master Direction.
Master Direction Reserve Bank of India Variation Margin Directions, 2022: The title of the policy document being analyzed, concerning variation margin requirements.
Foreign Exchange Management Act, 1999: An Indian law referenced in the document, related to foreign exchange management.
Non-centrally Cleared Derivatives (NCCDs): Financial derivatives that are not cleared through a central counterparty, and are the subject of this policy.
Indian Accounting Standard Ind AS: Accounting standards applicable to consolidated financial statements in India
Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI): A financial sector regulator in India
Bilateral Netting of Qualified Financial Contracts Act, 2020: Indian law related to netting agreements
Basel III Capital Regulations: International regulatory framework for banks
भारतीय �रज़व� ब�क
RESERVE BANK OF INDIA
RBI/2022-23/93
FMRD.DIRD.02/14.01.023/2022-23 June 01, 2022
To
All Eligible Market Participants
Madam/Sir
Master Direction – Reserve Bank of India (Variation Margin) Directions, 2022
Please refer to Paragraph 10 of the Statement on Developmental and Regulatory
Policies announced as a part of the Bi-monthly Monetary Policy Statement for 2019-
20 dated February 06, 2020, on issuance of the Directions regarding exchange of
variation margin (VM) for non-centrally cleared derivatives (NCCDs).
2. Accordingly, the draft Variation Margin (Reserve Bank) Directions, 2020 were
released for public comments on September 07, 2020. Based on the feedback
received from the market participants, the draft Directions were reviewed and have
since been finalised. The Master Direction – Reserve Bank of India (Variation Margin)
Directions, 2022 are enclosed herewith.
Yours faithfully,
(Dimple Bhandia)
Chief General ManagerFINANCIAL MARKETS REGULATION DEPARTMENT
Notification No. FMRD.DIRD.03/14.01.023/2022-23 dated June 01, 2022
Master Direction - Reserve Bank of India (Variation Margin) Directions, 2022
In exercise of the powers conferred under section 45W of the Reserve Bank of India
Act, 1934 (hereinafter called the Act) read with section 45U of the Act, the Reserve
Bank of India (hereinafter called the Reserve Bank) hereby issues the following
Directions.
A reference is also invited to the Foreign Exchange Management Act, 1999 (42 of
1999), Foreign Exchange Management (Foreign Exchange Derivative Contracts)
Regulations, 2000 (Notification no. FEMA.25/RB-2000 dated May 3, 2000), Foreign
Exchange Management (Debt Instruments) Regulations, 2019 (Notification No. FEMA
396/2019-RB dated October 17, 2019) and Foreign Exchange Management (Margin
for Derivative Contracts) Regulations, 2020 (Notification no. FEMA.399/RB-2020
dated October 23, 2020).
1. Short title and commencement
(1) These Directions shall be called the Master Direction – Reserve Bank of India
(Variation Margin) Directions, 2022.
(2) These Directions shall come into force with effect from December 01, 2022.
2. Applicability
(1) The provisions of these Directions shall apply to the following contracts, which are
entered into on or after the date on which these Directions come into force:
(a) Non-centrally cleared foreign exchange derivative contracts undertaken in
terms of the Foreign Exchange Management (Foreign Exchange Derivative
Contracts) Regulations, 2000 (Notification No. FEMA 25/RB-2000 dated May
3, 2000) and Master Direction – Risk Management and Inter-Bank Dealings
dated July 05, 2016, as amended from time to time;
(b) Non-centrally cleared interest rate derivative contracts undertaken in terms of
the Rupee Interest Rate Derivatives (Reserve Bank) Directions, 2019(Notification No. FMRD.DIRD.20/2019 dated June 26, 2019), as amended
from time to time;
(c) Non-centrally cleared credit derivative contracts undertaken in terms of
Master Direction – Reserve Bank of India (Credit Derivatives) Directions,
2022 (Notification No. FMRD.DIRD.11/14.03.004/2021-22 dated February
10, 2022), as amended from time to time; and
(d) Any other non-centrally cleared derivative (NCCD) contract as may be
specified by the Reserve Bank.
(2) Genuine amendments, including the following, to an existing derivative contract
entered into before the date on which these Directions come into force
(‘grandfathered contract’) will not qualify as a new derivative contract under these
Directions.
(a) non-material amendments that do not substantially change the terms and
conditions of the contract or create any new significant exposures;
(b) amendments made solely for the purpose of addressing benchmark reforms;
and
(c) contracts arising from novation, portfolio compression and application of
standard trade maintenance processes on grandfathered contracts.
Contracts resulting from compression of grandfathered contracts together
with contracts which are subject to these Directions shall, however, be subject
to the margin requirements under these Directions.
3. Definitions
(1) In these Directions, unless the context otherwise requires:
(a) Central counterparty means an entity that interposes itself between
counterparties to contracts traded in one or more financial markets, becoming
the buyer to every seller and the seller to every buyer and thereby ensuring
the performance of open contracts.
(b) Consolidated group means a group within the meaning of Indian Accounting
Standard (Ind AS) 110 - Consolidated Financial Statements, or International
Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) 10 - Consolidated Financial
Statements or any other equivalent accounting standards.
(c) Collateralise to market means an approach to the exchange of Variation
Margin wherein the exchanged margin is characterised as collateral to securethe current mark-to-market exposure between the parties to a derivative
contract.
(d) Financial sector regulator refers to the Reserve Bank of India (RBI), the
Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI), the Insurance Regulatory and
Development Authority of India (IRDAI) and the Pension Fund Regulatory and
Development Authority (PFRDA).
(e) Netting agreement shall have the same meaning as assigned to it in Section
2(1)(k) of The Bilateral Netting of Qualified Financial Contracts Act, 2020 (30
of 2020).
(f) Non-centrally cleared derivatives (NCCDs) mean derivative contracts
whose settlement is not guaranteed by a central counterparty.
(g) Non-resident means and includes a ‘person resident outside India’ as
defined in Section 2(w) of the Foreign Exchange Management Act, 1999 (42
of 1999).
(h) Related parties shall have the same meaning as assigned to it under Indian
Accounting Standard (Ind AS) 24 – Related Party Disclosures or International
Accounting Standard (IAS) 24 – Related Party Disclosures or any other
equivalent accounting standards.
(i) Resident means and includes a ‘person resident in India’ as defined in
Section 2(v) of the Foreign Exchange Management Act, 1999 (42 of 1999).
(j) Settle to market means an approach to the exchange of Variation Margin
wherein the exchanged margin is deemed to settle the current mark-to-market
exposure between the parties to a derivative contract, with no right to reclaim
and no obligation to return the Variation Margin. After the settlement, the
mark-to-market exposure between the parties is reset to zero.
(k) Variation margin means the collateral that is collected or paid to reflect the
current mark-to-market exposure resulting from changes in the market value
of a derivative contract.
(2) Words and expressions used but not defined in these Directions shall have the
meaning as assigned to them in the Reserve Bank of India Act, 1934.4. Entity Scope
4.1 Covered Entities
(1) The following entities shall be classified as Domestic Covered Entities under these
Directions:
(a) Entities regulated by a financial sector regulator (including branches of foreign
banks operating in India) and having an Average Aggregate Notional Amount
(AANA) of outstanding NCCDs of ₹25,000 crore and above, on a consolidated
group wide basis.
(b) Other resident entities having an AANA of outstanding NCCDs of ₹60,000
crore and above, on a consolidated group wide basis.
(2) The following entities shall be classified as Foreign Covered Entities under these
Directions:
(a) Non-resident financial entities having an AANA of outstanding NCCDs of USD
3 billion and above, on a consolidated group wide basis.1
(b) Other non-resident entities having an AANA of outstanding NCCDs of USD 8
billion and above, on a consolidated group wide basis.
(3) For the purposes of paragraph 4.1 (1) and (2), AANA of outstanding NCCDs shall
be calculated as set out in paragraph 4.2.
4.2 Average Aggregate Notional Amount of outstanding NCCDs
(1) AANA of outstanding NCCDs shall be calculated as the simple average of the total
notional amount of outstanding NCCDs as at the end of March, April and May of
a year. AANA for a year shall be used for recognition of Domestic Covered Entities
and Foreign Covered Entities for a one-year period from September 1 of that year
to August 31 of the next year.
(2) AANA calculation shall include all NCCD contracts of the consolidated group,
including those outside the scope of these Directions, but exclude intra-group
transactions.
1 For the purpose of these Directions, financial entities refer to entities which are engaged predominantly in any
one or more of the following activities – banking, lending, insurance, management of retirement fund schemes,
securities business, custodial and safekeeping services, portfolio management (including asset management and
funds management), securitisation, operation of a remittance or money changing service and activities that are
ancillary to the conduct of these activities.4.3 Directions for Covered Entities
(1) A Domestic Covered Entity shall exchange Variation Margin with a counterparty
to an NCCD transaction if the counterparty is a Domestic Covered Entity or a
Foreign Covered Entity. A Domestic Covered Entity shall put in place appropriate
processes for ascertaining whether a counterparty to an NCCD transaction is a
Domestic Covered Entity or a Foreign Covered Entity. For this purpose, Domestic
Covered Entities may, inter alia, rely on a declaration from the counterparties.
(2) The provisions of these Directions shall not apply to physically-settled foreign
exchange forward and physically-settled foreign exchange swap contracts.
However, Domestic Covered Entities are expected to appropriately manage the
risks associated with such transactions.2
(3) The provisions of these Directions shall not be applicable to an NCCD transaction
in which one of the counterparties is any of the following entities:
(a) Government of India and State Governments;
(b) A Foreign Sovereign;
(c) A Central Bank;
(d) Bank for International Settlements; and
(e) Multilateral Development Banks (MDBs) listed under paragraph 5.5 of RBI
Master Circular on Basel III Capital Regulations dated April 01, 20223, as
amended from time to time.
(4) The provisions of these Directions shall not be applicable to an NCCD transaction
between entities belonging to the same consolidated group.
5. Calculation and exchange of Variation Margin
(1) Variation Margin shall be calculated on a daily basis, and called and exchanged
at the earliest time possible after the transaction date (“T”) or margin recalculation
date (“R”), but no later than three local business days from the transaction date
(“T+3”) or margin recalculation date (“R+3”).
2 Domestic Covered Entities should refer to BCBS Supervisory Guidance for Managing Risks Associated with the
Settlement of FX Transactions, February 2013: https://www.bis.org/publ/bcbs241.pdf for management of FX-
settlement related risks.
3https://rbidocs.rbi.org.in/rdocs/notification/PDFs/12MCBASELIIICAPITALREGULATIONSED3EF388F75E48198F
F8328B36F43670.PDF(2) Variation Margin shall be exchanged to fully collateralise to market or settle to
market, the mark-to-market exposure of an NCCD contract. In the event that the
exposures cannot be marked-to-market, a pre-agreed alternative process or
fallback mechanism, as set out in the credit support annex, shall be used for the
purpose of calculation of Variation Margin.
(3) Variation Margin shall be calculated and exchanged on an aggregate net basis,
across all NCCD contracts that are executed under a single, legally enforceable
netting agreement.
(4) A minimum transfer amount, not exceeding ₹3.5 crore, may be applied for the
exchange of Variation Margin. The entire margin amount shall be exchanged if
the Variation Margin amount exceeds the minimum transfer amount.
(5) Variation Margin for an NCCD transaction between a Domestic Covered Entity
and a Foreign Covered Entity may be posted/collected either in India or in an
overseas jurisdiction, subject to the provisions of the A.P. (DIR Series) Circular
No. 10 dated February 15, 2021 on Margin for Derivative Contracts.
6. Eligible collateral and haircuts
(1) Variation Margin between two Domestic Covered Entities shall be exchanged
using the following collateral types:
(a) Indian Currency;
(b) Debt securities issued by Government of India and State Governments; and
(c) Rupee bonds issued by persons resident in India which are:
i. Listed on a recognised stock exchange in India; and
ii. Assigned a credit rating of AAA by a rating agency registered with the
Securities and Exchange Board of India. If different ratings are accorded
by two or more credit rating agencies, then the lowest rating shall be
reckoned.
(2) Variation Margin between a Domestic Covered Entity and a Foreign Covered
Entity shall be exchanged using the following collateral types, subject to the
provisions of the A.P. (DIR Series) Circular No. 10 dated February 15, 2021 on
Margin for Derivative Contracts:
(a) Indian currency;
(b) Freely convertible foreign currency;
(c) Debt securities issued by Government of India and State Governments;(d) Debt securities issued by foreign sovereigns with a credit rating of AA- and
above issued by S&P Global Ratings / Fitch Ratings or Aa3 and above issued
by Moody’s Investors Service. If different ratings are accorded by two or more
credit rating agencies, then the lowest rating shall be reckoned; and
(e) Rupee bonds issued by persons resident in India which are:
a. Listed on a recognised stock exchange in India; and
b. Assigned a credit rating of AAA by a rating agency registered with the
Securities and Exchange Board of India. If different ratings are accorded
by two or more credit rating agencies, then the lowest rating shall be
reckoned.
(3) Risk-sensitive haircuts shall be applied to the value of the collateral received. A
schedule of minimum haircuts to be applied to the collateral received based on
the type of collateral is set out in Annex. An additional haircut of 8% shall be
applied to all non-cash collateral received in a currency other than the base
currency of the NCCD transaction or eligible currencies as agreed to in the credit
support annex.
(4) Securities issued by either of the counterparties to an NCCD transaction, or their
related parties, shall not be accepted as collateral.
(5) Counterparties shall establish appropriate controls to manage the risks associated
with the collateral received including, inter-alia, wrong-way risk4, concentration
risk and liquidity risk.
7. Treatment of collateral under collateralise to market approach
(1) Cash collateral received as Variation Margin by banks shall not be treated as
deposits, and the provisions of Master Direction – Reserve Bank of India (Interest
Rate on Deposits) Directions, 2016, as amended from time to time, shall not be
applicable to it.
(2) Cash collateral received as Variation Margin by Authorised Dealers shall not be
treated as borrowings, and the provisions under Paragraph 5 of Part C of the
Master Direction - Risk Management and Inter-Bank Dealings, 2016, as amended
from time to time, shall not be applicable to it.
4 Wrong-way risk occurs when the value of the collateral collected exhibits a significant correlation with the
creditworthiness of the counterparty or the value of the underlying NCCD portfolio in a way that could
undermine the effectiveness of the protection offered by the collateral collected.(3) Counterparties may pay interest on cash collateral received as Variation Margin,
in terms of the credit support annex.
(4) Cash and non-cash collateral received as Variation Margin may be re-
hypothecated, re-pledged or re-used, in terms of the credit support annex.
8. Margin requirements for cross-border transactions
(1) An NCCD transaction between a Domestic Covered Entity and a Foreign Covered
Entity may be subject to margin requirements in a foreign jurisdiction. A Domestic
Covered Entity and its counterparty in the foreign jurisdiction may decide to
comply with these Directions, or the margin requirements implemented by the
foreign jurisdiction provided the margining framework in the foreign jurisdiction is
assessed by the Domestic Covered Entity to be comparable to the requirements
in these Directions.
(2) The Domestic Covered Entity shall assess the comparability of the margining
framework of the foreign jurisdictions based on the following broad principles:
(a) the foreign jurisdiction whose margining framework is being assessed is a
member of the BCBS-IOSCO Working Group on Margin Requirements;
(b) the margining framework in the foreign jurisdiction is implemented in line with
the policy framework on margin requirements for NCCDs issued by BCBS
and IOSCO; and
(c) the foreign jurisdiction has a legally enforceable netting framework;
(3) For this purpose, the Domestic Covered Entity shall put in place a Board-approved
policy for the comparability assessment. The assessment of the margining
framework of each foreign jurisdiction shall be placed before the Risk
Management Committee of the Board/ equivalent body and subject to periodic
review.
(4) The Domestic Covered Entity intending to comply with the margining framework
of a foreign jurisdiction shall comply with the provisions of the A.P. (DIR Series)
Circular No. 10 dated February 15, 2021 on Margin for Derivative Contracts.
(5) The Reserve Bank may, at a future date, undertake comparability assessment of
margining framework of foreign jurisdictions vis-à-vis these Directions. Such
assessment would have regard to whether the margining framework in the foreign
jurisdiction is implemented in line with the policy framework on margin
requirements for NCCDs issued by the BCBS and IOSCO.(6) The Reserve Bank, based on its assessment of the margining framework of a
foreign jurisdiction, may impose additional conditions to be met by the
counterparties intending to comply with the margining framework of that
jurisdiction.
(7) A Domestic Covered Entity may not exchange Variation Margin in an NCCD
transaction with a Foreign Covered Entity if there is significant doubt regarding the
enforceability of close-out netting and/or collateral arrangements, subject to the
following:
(a) The Domestic Covered Entity shall undertake a legal review and document
the basis for identifying a jurisdiction where close-out netting and/or collateral
arrangements are not legally enforceable; and
(b) For each jurisdiction so assessed, the Domestic Covered Entity shall put in
place appropriate internal limits and controls to manage its exposure to
counterparties located in the jurisdiction.
9. Dispute resolution
(1) Counterparties shall ensure that appropriate policies and procedures for dispute
resolution are in place before undertaking an NCCD transaction. Such policies
and procedures shall, inter-alia, include processes for determining discrepancies
in material terms or valuations as disputes, mechanism for such disputes to be
resolved and escalation of material disputes to senior management, or to the
Board, as may be appropriate.
(2) In case of a margin dispute, counterparties shall exchange the non-disputed
amount first and make all necessary and appropriate efforts, including timely
initiation of dispute resolution protocols, to resolve the dispute and exchange the
remaining Variation Margin amount in a time-bound manner.
(Dimple Bhandia)
Chief General ManagerAnnex
Standardised Haircut Schedule
Haircut
Asset Class
(% of market value)
Cash 0
Debt securities issued by Residual maturity ≤ 1 year 0.5
Government of India and
Residual maturity > 1 year, ≤
state governments / 2
5 years
foreign central
governments Residual maturity > 5 years 4
Residual maturity ≤ 1 year 4
Listed Rupee bonds
issued by persons Residual maturity > 1 year, ≤
6
resident in India and with a 5 years
credit rating of AAA
Residual maturity > 5 years 8
Additional (additive) haircut on listed Rupee bonds issued
by financial institutions (to address possible wrong way 5
risk)
Additional (additive) haircut for currency mismatch 8