**Executive Summary**
This document is the answer provided by the Minister of State in the Ministry of Rural Development to Lok Sabha Unstarred Question No. 1419, answered on December 9, 2025. The question sought details regarding the monitoring of the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme (MGNREGS) in Kerala, including financial misappropriation, fake job cards, social audits, fund recovery, and measures to strengthen monitoring. The document details financial misappropriations and fake job cards detected in the last three financial years and outlines measures implemented to strengthen MGNREGS monitoring.
**Key Points / Main Content**
* **Financial Misappropriation (As per Government of Kerala):**
* 2022-23: 394 cases, Rs. 27,90,206 identified.
* 2023-24: 2185 cases, Rs. 54,68,709 identified.
* 2024-25: 5732 cases, Rs. 51,49,568 identified.
* **Fake Job Cards Deleted:**
* 2022-23: 1471
* 2023-24: 316
* 2024-25: 108
* Gram Panchayat officials deleted the duplicate job cards using "fake job cards" as the reason, as there was no option to mark job cards as duplicate in NREGA Soft.
* **Social Audit:**
* An independent Social Audit Unit has been established in Kerala.
* Audits are conducted every six months for all works under the scheme.
* Details of Social Audit conducted in the last three financial years are given at Annexure-l.
* Social Audit Findings: Citizens information board installation issues, Measurement related issues, Wages paid to workers who marked attendance in NMMS but were marked absent in the manual muster roll, more labour days were provided for LIFE/PMAY houses than the stage of completion warranted, Overwriting/corrections in the entries recorded in the M-Book, Worksite facilities not fully provided, RozgarDiwas not being conducted regularly.
* **Fund Recovery:**
* Action has been taken to recover misappropriated funds.
* Amounts recovered align with misappropriation identified for each year.
* 2022-23: Rs. 27,90,206
* 2023-24: Rs. 54,68,709
* 2024-25: Rs. 51,49,568
* **Measures to Strengthen Monitoring:**
* MGNREGS is implemented on NREGASoft, an integrated transaction-based Management Information System (MIS).
* All aspects of the scheme, from planning to payment, are monitored through NREGASoft and Direct Benefit Transfer (DBT)-Public Financial Management System (PFMS).
* Transparency and accountability are emphasized.
* Use of technology includes:
* Direct Benefit Transfer (DBT)
* National Mobile Monitoring Service (NMMS)
* Area Officer Monitoring Visit Application
* GIS based plan
* Yuktdhara
* SECURE
* GeoNREGA
* JALDOOT App
* JANMANREGA App
* Ombudsperson App
* Social Audit
**Impact Analysis**
**Government of Kerala**
* **Impact:** The Government of Kerala is responsible for providing the initial data on financial misappropriation and fake job cards.
* **Action Required:** Continue to furnish accurate data to the Ministry of Rural Development and cooperate with measures to improve MGNREGS implementation.
**Ministry of Rural Development**
* **Impact:** The ministry is responsible for monitoring and ensuring transparency and accountability in MGNREGS implementation across states/UTs, including Kerala.
* **Action Required:** Continue to implement and refine monitoring measures, including the use of technology and social audits, to prevent and address financial misappropriation.
**MGNREGS Workers in Kerala**
* **Impact:** Workers are affected by financial misappropriation and fake job cards, which can impact their access to employment and wages.
* **Action Required:** Be aware of their rights under MGNREGS, report any irregularities, and participate in social audits to ensure proper implementation.
**Gram Panchayats in Kerala**
* **Impact:** Responsible for implementing MGNREGS at the local level and ensuring accurate record-keeping.
* **Action Required:** Improve record-keeping practices, ensure proper deletion of fake job cards, and cooperate with social audits.
Key Entities Referenced
Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme (MGNREGS): A demand-driven wage employment scheme aiming to enhance livelihood security of households in rural areas by providing at least one hundred days of guaranteed wage employment in a financial year to every household whose adult members volunteer to do unskilled manual work.
Ministry of Rural Development: The central government ministry responsible for the administration and monitoring of MGNREGS.
Kerala: The state where the MGNREGS implementation and associated issues (financial misappropriation, fake job cards) are being examined.
GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
MINISTRY OF RURAL DEVELOPMENT
DEPARTMENT OF RURAL DEVELOPMENT
LOK SABHA
UNSTARRED QUESTION NO. 1419
ANSWERED ON 09/12/2025
MONITORING OF MGNREGS IN KERALA
1419. Dr. ShashiTharoor:
Will the Minister of RURAL DEVELOPMENT be pleased to state:
(a) the details and total number of cases of financial
misappropriation detected under Mahatma Gandhi National
Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme (MGNREGS) in Kerala
during the last three financial years and the total amount
misappropriated;
(b) the details and total number of fake job cards deleted in Kerala
during the last three financial years;
(c) whether the Ministry has conducted any social audits in Kerala
to assess the implementation of MGNREGS, if so, the findings
thereof;
(d) the steps taken to recover misappropriated funds in Kerala,
and the amount recovered so far; and
(e) the measures implemented to strengthen monitoring and
accountability in the implementation of MGNREGS in Kerala,
including the use of technology and social audits?
ANSWER
MINISTER OF STATE IN THE MINISTRY OF RURAL DEVELOPMENT
(SHRI KAMLESH PASWAN)
(a): As per the information furnished by the Government of Kerala,
the details of cases of financial misappropriation detected under
the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme
(Mahatma Gandhi NREGS) during the last three financial years are
as under:
Financial Number of cases of financial Amount
Year misappropriation Identified Rs
2022-23 394 27,90,206
2023-24 2185 54,68,709
2024-25 5732 51,49,568
Page 1 of 6(b): Details of fake job cards deleted in Kerala Mahatma Gandhi
NREGS during the last three financial years are given below:
Financial Year Number of fake job cards deleted*
2022-23 1471
2023-24 316
2024-25 108
* As per the information received from the Kerala Government,
since at the time of deletion of job cards, there was no option
available in the NREGA Soft to mark the job card as duplicate
hence, the Gram Panchayat officials have deleted the duplicate job
cards by giving the reason of fake job cards.
(c): An independent Social Audit Unit has been established in the
state of Kerala for conducting Social Audit. This audit process is
conducted once in every six months for all works taken up under
the scheme. The details of Social Audit conducted in the last three
financial years are given at Annexure-I.
(d): Action has been taken to recover the amount involved in the
financial misappropriation cases. The details of the amount
recovered so far given below.
Financial Year Amount recovered (in Rs.)
2022-23 27,90,206
2023-24 54,68,709
2024-25 51,49,568
(e): Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee
Scheme (Mahatma Gandhi NREGS) is a demand-driven wage
employment Scheme. The Scheme is implemented on an end-to-end
integrated transaction-based Management Information System (MIS)
platform called NREGASoft. Through this, all aspects relating to
planning, administrative and technical approval of the scheme,
issue of job cards, acceptance of demand, issue of muster roll,
measurement of work, approval of payment and finally payment to
the beneficiary through a Direct Benefit Transfer (DBT)-Public
Financial Management System (PFMS) platform are monitored.
Page 2 of 6Transparency and accountability are the prime focus of the
scheme. Ministry of Rural Development has adopted robust process
for ensuring transparency and accountability in the implementation
of the scheme across the States/UTs. A brief note on the various
monitoring and evaluation arrangements, including technological
interventions made for ensuring proper utilization of the funds
released under the scheme is given at Annexure-II.
*****
Page 3 of 6Annexure-I
Annexure referred to in reply to part (c) of LokSabhaUnstarred
Question No. 1419 dated 09.12.2025.
Financial Total No. of GPs No. of Audit Financial Major Findings in Social Audit
Year No. of where observations Misappropriation
GPs Social Audit Recoveries done
conducted
2022 – 23 941 936 6,894 27,90,206 Issues related to Citizen
Information Board
Installation.
Measurement related
2023 - 24 941 941 14,968 54,68,709 issues.
Wages were paid to
workers who marked
attendance in NMMS but
were marked absent in the
manual muster roll.
More labour days were
2024 – 25 941 941 48,420 51,49,568
provided for LIFE/PMAY
houses than the stage of
completion warranted.
Overwriting/corrections in
the entries recorded in the
M-Book.
Worksite facilities are not
fully provided.
RozgarDiwas is not being
conducted regularly.
Page 4 of 6Annexure-II
Annexure referred to in reply to part (e) of LokSabhaUnstarred
Question No. 1419 dated 09.12.2025.
i. Direct Benefit Transfer (DBT): Direct Benefit Transfer (DBT)
system in wage payment has been adopted under Mahatma
Gandhi National Rural Employment Scheme (Mahatma Gandhi
NREGS). The payment of wages to the bank/ post office
accounts of Mahatma Gandhi NREGS workers is through
National Electronic Fund Management System
(NeFMS)/Electronic Fund Management System (eFMS).
ii. National Mobile Monitoring Service (NMMS): It enables
capturing of attendance of workers at Mahatma Gandhi
NREGA worksites (except for individual beneficiary works)
along with geo-tagged photographs twice in a day. This app
aids in increasing citizen oversight of the programme. This is
one more step towards transparency and accountability.
iii. Area Officer Monitoring Visit Application: This App facilitates
the officials of the State/UT to record their field visit findings
online. The App also allows the officials to record time-
stamped and geotagged photographs for all the schemes
launched by the Department of Rural Development. Also, this
App helps in developing hassle-free reporting of the field visits.
This app records the field visit findings and views the field
visit outcome report by the senior officials.
iv. GIS based plan: Use of Space Technology: GIS based GP level
plan (ridge to valley approach) preparation using Remote
Sensing technology in a saturation mode for all the GPs of the
country.
v. Yuktdhara: GIS based planning tool – To simplify the GIS
based planning at GP level under Mahatma Gandhi NREGA
“Yuktdhara” a Geospatial planning portal is developed in
collaboration with ISRO-NRSC.
vi. SECURE: Software for Estimate Calculation for using Rural
Rates for Employment :-Application is being used to estimate
the cost of works to be undertaken under the scheme.
vii. GeoNREGA: the app has been developed by using Space
Technology to track the creation of assets by geotagging it, at
“Before”, “During” and “After” stages of the asset creation.
viii. JALDOOT App: JALDOOT app has been developed to enable
monitoring of ground water tables across the country. The
Page 5 of 6Jaldoot app enables Gram RojgarSahayak (GRS) to measure
the water level of selected wells twice a year (pre-
monsoonand post-monsoon).
ix. JANMANREGA app: this app helps in proactive disclosure of
information to its citizens in reference to the implementation
of Mahatma Gandhi NREGS. Citizen awareness is a key to
efficient, effective, and transparent execution of the scheme.
x. Ombudsperson App: An Ombudsperson App has been
developed for smooth reporting and categorization of
grievances received from various sources viz. physical, digital
and mass media related to the implementation of the Mahatma
Gandhi NREGS, easy tracking and timely passing of awards on
each case as per the guidelines and easy uploading of
quarterly and annual report on the website.
xi. Social Audit: As per the mandate of the Act, the Ministry has
laid emphasis on the setting up of an institutional structure at
the States/UTs level for facilitating social audits of all the
Gram Panchayats at least twice a year. With the consistent
efforts by Ministry, a total of 27 States and 1 UT have
established Independent Social Audit Units.
Further, monitoring by National level monitors, regular and special
monitoring, monitoring by team of central government officers,
monitoring visits by Common review Mission teams, monitoring
through use of Area Officers app is being conducted for better
implementation of the programme. Also, State/UT specific reviews
are also undertaken from time to time.
*****
Page 6 of 6