Executive Summary:
The Ministry of Health and Family Welfare addresses concerns regarding misconduct by health insurance companies towards medical practitioners. The response clarifies that no related complaints have been received by the National Health Authority (NHA). It outlines existing regulations and measures by the Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India (IRDAI) to ensure transparency, efficient claim settlements, and dispute resolution in the health insurance sector.
Key Points / Main Content:
Complaints and Information:
* No complaints or information regarding misconduct by health insurance companies towards medical practitioners to avoid claim settlements have been received by the NHA.
State Responsibilities:
* Health and Law and Order are State subjects, making States/UTs primarily responsible for preventing violence against medical professionals.
* Many States have enacted laws addressing violence against medical professionals, with major offenses covered under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), 2023.
IRDAI Regulations and Measures:
* IRDAI mandates Health Services Agreements between insurers, Third Party Administrators (TPAs), and network providers, outlining terms and conditions of services.
* These agreements, as per the IRDAI TPA Regulations 2016, must include Arbitration and Dispute Resolution clauses for resolving disputes.
* IRDAI has revamped the health insurance framework, notifying IRDAI (Insurance Products) Regulations, 2024, and issuing a Master Circular on Health Insurance Business to enhance transparency and improve customer claim settlement experiences.
Expected Outcomes:
* The measures are expected to lead to better-informed policyholders.
* They aim to ensure transparency and efficiency in claim settlements.
* The measures also intend to reduce grievances, disputes, and delays in claim processing.
* Ultimately, the measures aim to create a seamless health insurance experience for policyholders.
Impact Analysis:
Medical Practitioners:
Impact: While no specific misconduct complaints have been directly addressed, existing state laws and dispute resolution mechanisms within Health Services Agreements offer avenues for addressing grievances.
Action Required: Be aware of state laws addressing violence against medical professionals and utilize Arbitration and Dispute Resolution clauses in Health Services Agreements for resolving disputes.
Health Insurance Companies and TPAs:
Impact: The IRDAI regulations and circulars emphasize transparency, efficient claim settlements, and adherence to dispute resolution mechanisms, impacting their operational practices.
Action Required: Ensure compliance with IRDAI TPA Regulations 2016, IRDAI (Insurance Products) Regulations, 2024, and the Master Circular on Health Insurance Business. Adhere to Arbitration and Dispute Resolution clauses in Health Services Agreements.
Policyholders:
Impact: The revamped health insurance framework and measures by IRDAI are intended to improve their claim settlement experience, reduce grievances, and provide a more seamless health insurance process.
Action Required: Stay informed about their rights and the terms of their health insurance policies. Utilize the dispute resolution mechanisms available to address grievances related to claim settlements.
States/UTs:
Impact: The clarification reinforces their primary responsibility for maintaining law and order and preventing violence against medical professionals.
Action Required: Continue to enforce existing laws addressing violence against medical professionals and take appropriate action to prevent such incidents.
Key Entities Referenced
Ministry of Health and Family Welfare: The Indian government ministry responsible for health policy in India.
National Health Authority (NHA): An entity under the Government of India, likely responsible for implementing health schemes and policies.
Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India (IRDAI): The regulatory body for the insurance sector in India.
Third Party Administrator (TPA): An organization that processes insurance claims and performs other administrative services for health insurers.
Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), 2023: A major criminal law of India, likely replacing the Indian Penal Code.
IRDAI TPA Regulations 2016: Regulations by IRDAI governing the operations of Third Party Administrators in the health insurance sector.
IRDAI Insurance Products Regulations, 2024: Regulations by IRDAI governing health insurance products.
States and Union Territories of India: Refers to the individual states and union territories within India, highlighting their responsibility for health and law & order.
GOVERNMENTOFINDIA
MINISTRYOFHEALTH AND FAMILYWELFARE
DEPARTMENTOFHEALTH ANDFAMILYWELFARE
LOK SABHA
UNSTARREDQUESTION NO. 1007
TOBE ANSWERED ON25TH JULY,2025
MISCONDUCTOFHEALTH INSURANCECOMPANIES
1007. DR. BACHHAVSHOBHADINESH:
Will the Ministerof HEALTHANDFAMILYWELFAREbe pleased tostate:
(a) whether the Government has taken cognizance of the misconduct of Health Insurance
Companiestowards medicalpractitioners toavoidsettlement of claims, if so,details thereof;
(b) whether the Government has instituted an enquiry to review complains of doctors and
nurses regarding harassment faced by them from health insurance companies, if so, the
detailsthereofandif not, the reasons therefor;
(c) whether the Government has formulated any concrete policies to ensure protection of
rightsof the medicaland healthcareworkers of the countryandif so, the detailsthereof; and
(d) whether the Government plans to formulate and enact a comprehensive legislation with
regards to regulating the conduct of health insurance companies, towards medical
practitionersandif so, the details thereof?
ANSWER
THE MINISTER OFSTATEIN THE MINISTRYOFHEALTHAND
FAMILYWELFARE
(SHRIPRATAPRAOJADHAV)
(a) to (d): No such complaints or information regarding misconduct by health insurance
companies towards medical practitioners with the intent to avoid settlement of claims have
beenreceivedbythe National HealthAuthority (NHA).
As per Constitutional provisions, ‘Health’ and ‘Law and Order’ are State subjects. It is the
primary responsibility of the concerned State/UT to take note of events and eventualities for
taking appropriate action to prevent violence against medical professionals. Further, many
States have enacted laws to address violence against medical professionals. Most of the State
laws cover minor offences and prescribe punishment for them. Major offences / heinous
crimesare adequately coveredunderBharatiya Nyaya Sanhita(BNS),2023.
Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India (IRDAI) has informed that in
terms of Regulation 2(i) of the TPA Regulations 2016, it has mandated that the insurers andTPAs shall enter into “Health Services Agreement” laying down the terms and conditions of
services which maybe renderedto the policyholdersandmaybe enteredintobetween:
a Third-PartyAdministrator (TPA)andaninsurer; or
a Network providerandaninsurer; or
a Network provider, a TPAandthe insurer
The Health Services Agreements lay down the scope and obligations of each party to the
agreementandthe services are renderedasperthe agreedclauses.
IRDAI has also issued Master Circular on IRDAI (TPA) Regulations2016.As perthe Master
Circular, it is specified that the agreements entered into by insurers, TPAs and network
providers, shall have Arbitration and Dispute Resolution clause. Therefore, any
dispute/violation arising out of the operation of agreed clause is within the realm of the
partiestoresolve.
As regards to settlement of claims, it is submitted that the IRDAI has revamped health
insurance framework andnotified IRDAI(Insurance Products)–Regulations, 2024andissued
a Master Circular on Health Insurance Business in order to bring in more transparency andto
improve the customer claim settlement experience among others. These steps are expected to
result in better-informed policyholders, ensure transparency and efficiency in settlement of
claims, reduced grievances, disputes and delays, and a seamless health insurance experience
for policyholders.
*****